Supreme365
Superstar
Better career?
Better peak?
Who'd you rather build around if they were both prospects?
Vick vs Mcnabb
- Thread starter Supreme365
- Start date
Better career?
Better peak?
Who'd you rather build around if they were both prospects?
PortCityProphet
Follow me to the truth
McNabb and it's not even close.
Yall really don't realize how trash Mike Vick was a complete QB. Dude couldn't do shyt but run.
Don't ever compare him to the Don again
Yall really don't realize how trash Mike Vick was a complete QB. Dude couldn't do shyt but run.
Don't ever compare him to the Don again
filial_piety
Banned
Snippets don't tell the whole story...
Vick is more exciting...but Mcnabb is better all around...
He took the Eagles to 4 straight NFC championships starting from his first season as a starter...and this was no Dak Presscott situation....he carried the weight on that team.
Vick is more exciting...but Mcnabb is better all around...
He took the Eagles to 4 straight NFC championships starting from his first season as a starter...and this was no Dak Presscott situation....he carried the weight on that team.
sometimes thats all you need to do. Word to Forrest Gump.
Supreme365
Superstar
Vick's 10' season is just as good if not better than Mcnabb's best year
number21
Strive for rulership not equality, black man.
McNabb, McNabb, and McNabb. The only argument you can make for Vick is for better peak and that's based on one year for Vick.
El Coupeacabra
Diamond Teeth Samurai
McNabb had his days where he was damn near perfect. He still owns the record for consecutive passes completed right?
It's a weird situation.
On any single play, Vick can hurt you more, hands down.
But over the course of a season, McNabb's creativity in the pocket and consistency makes it pretty close to even.
It's closer than what guys are saying in here.
It's a weird situation.
On any single play, Vick can hurt you more, hands down.
But over the course of a season, McNabb's creativity in the pocket and consistency makes it pretty close to even.
It's closer than what guys are saying in here.
