Just saw it.
My biggest hangup about the film is the tethered having the same/similar clothes as the folks upstairs. To me it would have made more sense if the tethered were naked but obtained the red outfits later. For clarification on the clothes: I mean the similar looking Thriller shirt which was faded, the ballerina dress, all the tethered downstairs wearing similar clothes to the folks upstairs during the opening, etc.
Brings it more into a supernatural territory. Which is fine but still. Got me thinking of Resident Evil (tangent), though obviously they aren't zombies. As you get closer to the labs in the original Resident Evil 1 or 2 (?) you see that the zombies don't have clothes. They are completely naked.
The tethered actually reenacting everything happening above AND having clothes that their 'other' is wearing kind of...I don't know. Maybe because everything was so grounded that I didn't think that the supernatural would play a factor? I don't know.
--
Also, I don't have a problem with the dad being suburban, goofy, etc but there's a time when even a suburban dad knows that it's time to get serious and stop making jokes. People are trying to kill your family breh. In terms of his character there was actually a good deleted scene with him and his daughter.
I actually think it's a good scene and wish it stayed in the film. It gave more insight into him and I like the father/daughter relationship being shown more. It reveals more of their bond and the father's reliance on the strength of his wife while simultaneously trying to remain strong in front of their daughter. To me it's a scene that makes him strong in the sense that he's trying to reassure his daughter but revealing a vulnerable side of himself at the same time.
--
Kinda felt the end was unnecessary.
--
Overall I appreciate Jordan Peele and what he's doing with genre. Interested in seeing where he goes next.