TSC Evaluation #112: Shawn Michaels
- Thread starter mrken12
- Start date
All thein this thread over a poll.
Even if there weren't any 1s or 4s being given out, people would be complaining about the 7s and 8s.
right, nikkas crying over a poll where results have Trish Status listed better than The Undertaker
wrestling fans be acting like hoes sometimes, no wonder Cokeboy doesn't listen to em
Judging by this thread, there’s gonna be a LOT of hurt feelings in the Rock and Austin threads. All I’m saying now is nikkas better be ready for the TSCKliq and others to derail the threads and skew those scores 
@mrken12 as much as it pains me to say it, but you may as well add Hoegan (
) to the rotation if we evaluating the big big names
Speaking of which, where Kliq Task Force generals @Ravishing Brick Rude @charmander for their HBGOAT evaluations?
@mrken12 as much as it pains me to say it, but you may as well add Hoegan (
) to the rotation if we evaluating the big big namesSpeaking of which, where Kliq Task Force generals @Ravishing Brick Rude @charmander for their HBGOAT evaluations?
Last edited:
Lowkey this thread kinda proves @Rarely-Wrong Liggins right about certain shyt he’s been saying regarding TSC lately 
Berniewood Hogan
IT'S BERNIE SANDERS WITH A STEEL CHAIR!
Trish Stratus is hotter than the Undertaker.right, nikkas crying over a poll where results have Trish Status listed better than The Undertaker
malbaker86
Gators
Only 10's I'd give is to:
Bret
Hbk
Hogan
Rock
Austin
Savage
Flair
Jericho
Bret
Hbk
Hogan
Rock
Austin
Savage
Flair
Jericho
Francis White
i been away to long, my feeling died.
To be fair anything under 5 should be removed, you know they are doing it on purpose.All the
Even if there weren't any 1s or 4s being given out, people would be complaining about the 7s and 8s.
Francis White
i been away to long, my feeling died.
As a proud member of The KLIQ, I will rate Rock fair. He is a legend. Bigger than Hogan in my eyes. He is a 10. Austin is not.Judging by this thread, there’s gonna be a LOT of hurt feelings in the Rock and Austin threads. All I’m saying now is nikkas better be ready for the TSCKliq and others to derail the threads and skew those scores
@mrken12 as much as it pains me to say it, but you may as well add Hoegan (
Speaking of which, where Kliq Task Force generals @Ravishing Brick Rude @charmander for their HBGOAT evaluations?
NYChase718
Veteran
Golayitdown
Veteran
I guess I'll take the heat as I justify my rating.
Ring Work: (10) As gifted as he was between the ropes, can't see giving him less than a 10. I don't think he's the GOAT by any stretch of the imagination (just not my style of wrestler) but he was damn talented from basically beginning until his very last match.
Mic Work/Promos: (7) As good as he was in the ring he was generally (taking his whole career into account) meh on the mic. He could go out and talk, but outside of his DX heel run (his Magnum Opus), he was nothing to write home about. This is even more apparent every time he makes appearances these days. The one thing that doesn't fail a wrestler (barring mental issues) is the mic work. For him to be such a hailed wrestler (on here and by WWE in general) and be called the compete package so much, his promos/mic work highlights don't compare to other zero tier legends (Rock, Austin, Flair, Macho, etc.) and is far behind most of the members of the Kliq (HHH, Nash, Hall). This is the one area where he's completely outclassed by most greats.
Gimmicks: (8) as a solo guy, he was made to be a heel. Thats where he did his best work. He was an absolute terrible "good guy" and I disliked almost all of his face runs (except the slave to JBL run
) . His great runs (DX heel) are offset by his bad runs (the boyhood dream that almost sank the company). His whole second run was carried by his ring work vs. his character work. Overall I can say he was memorable though.
Overall: 8. If wrestling was just about wrestling in the ring, he would be near the top of the list. Taking in all aspects of the craft (character, promos, gimmicks, etc) he's definitely above average but nowhere near my Mount Rushmore.
Ring Work: (10) As gifted as he was between the ropes, can't see giving him less than a 10. I don't think he's the GOAT by any stretch of the imagination (just not my style of wrestler) but he was damn talented from basically beginning until his very last match.
Mic Work/Promos: (7) As good as he was in the ring he was generally (taking his whole career into account) meh on the mic. He could go out and talk, but outside of his DX heel run (his Magnum Opus), he was nothing to write home about. This is even more apparent every time he makes appearances these days. The one thing that doesn't fail a wrestler (barring mental issues) is the mic work. For him to be such a hailed wrestler (on here and by WWE in general) and be called the compete package so much, his promos/mic work highlights don't compare to other zero tier legends (Rock, Austin, Flair, Macho, etc.) and is far behind most of the members of the Kliq (HHH, Nash, Hall). This is the one area where he's completely outclassed by most greats.
Gimmicks: (8) as a solo guy, he was made to be a heel. Thats where he did his best work. He was an absolute terrible "good guy" and I disliked almost all of his face runs (except the slave to JBL run
) . His great runs (DX heel) are offset by his bad runs (the boyhood dream that almost sank the company). His whole second run was carried by his ring work vs. his character work. Overall I can say he was memorable though.Overall: 8. If wrestling was just about wrestling in the ring, he would be near the top of the list. Taking in all aspects of the craft (character, promos, gimmicks, etc) he's definitely above average but nowhere near my Mount Rushmore.
Last edited:
First you were skeptical of me being unbiased during the creation of the thread. Now you want votes removed because you don't like the results.
Francis White
i been away to long, my feeling died.
First you were skeptical of me being unbiased during the creation of the thread. Now you want votes removed because you don't like the results.
Sometimes the target you want to hit moves and you hit strays. So yes those people who voted less than 5 should not count.
Redguard
Hoonding
8.
For the same reasons @Golayitdown said.
Excellent wrestler. Terrible draw. I just finished watching WWF 96 and he is a terrible face. Plus if he didn't have back problems in early 98 he probably wouldn't have dropped the WWF title to Austin.
For the same reasons @Golayitdown said.
Excellent wrestler. Terrible draw. I just finished watching WWF 96 and he is a terrible face. Plus if he didn't have back problems in early 98 he probably wouldn't have dropped the WWF title to Austin.