As far as the ones I actually played, Nitro, Thunder, Warzone, Power Move Pro Wrestling, and Legends of Wrestling are the worst wrestling games ever.
Everybody knows why Nitro and Thunder sucked. Barely any moves, sluggish gameplay, and the characters get up immediately when you do a finisher, on some Warrior/HHH WM 12 shyt
Warzone (and Attitude) had great sound, but that's it. The graphics sucked, blood would be on the most mind-numbing places during hardcore matches, and you had to hit very lengthy button combinations just to do a hiptoss.
Power Move Pro Wrestling had no commentary and horrendous sound. Was terrible controls too.
Legends of Wrestling may be the most disappointing one on my list cause you had an amazing concept bringing back a lot of legends, but failed in every other way possible. Terrible controls, weak career mode, and unmemorable CAW mode. The best aspect of the game was simply the idea of playing with nothing but legends at their peak. Everything else was awful. A game like that really needs an update.
Raw is War for XBOX is worse than all the games y'all mentioning.
Anyone play Royal Rumble for Dreamcast
RR for the time had really good graphics and game speed, but really nothing else. The best thing about that game was being able to have 9 or so guys in the ring at the same time. No CAW mode, no career mode, and not enough characters. It was literally the Royal Rumble and nothing else lol.