nyknick

refuel w/ chocolate milk
Joined
Jul 7, 2012
Messages
18,714
Reputation
6,060
Daps
90,732
The hostages should be released without conditions. One of the injured hostages that I've read about is even American. The fact a "state" wouldn't even hold hostages and do what Hamas has done here should give everyone pause.


I haven't moved any goal posts lol. If Israel doesn't want to accept what Hamas is offering... ultimately that's up to them. I don't think we have a clear picture on these negotiations. Well at least I don't feel that I do. I would prefer if Hamas can come to terms before Israel goes into Rafah.


Did you know the Met Gala is tonight?
I'm apparently one of the few that gives a damn about the hostages.


Save the gay weirdo talk for your buddies, I'm not one of them.
We already have a clear picture of negotiations and know why hostages have not been released. Haim Rubenstein resigned as spokesperson for families of hostages so you should step in since you apparently give more damn about the hostages than he does.

 

88m3

Fast Money & Foreign Objects
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
88,173
Reputation
3,616
Daps
157,198
Reppin
Brooklyn
We already have a clear picture of negotiations and know why hostages have not been released. Haim Rubenstein resigned as spokesperson for families of hostages so you should step in since you apparently give more damn about the hostages than he does.



I honestly don't think so, there is an almost unparalleled amount of disinformation and psychological warfare taking place

We should all have a hard time taking leaks about the negotiations that are taking place at face value until something is agreed to

I have no doubt that Netanyahu and Hamas leadership are exploiting the situation to their maximum personal benefit
 

bnew

Veteran
Joined
Nov 1, 2015
Messages
55,695
Reputation
8,224
Daps
157,204

Top Secret: In a 2018 letter, Netanyahu asks Qatar to fund Hamas​


In letter seen by handful of people, PM urges Doha to deliver $30 million to Gaza monthly, claiming funding Hamas would preserve regional stability and avert humanitarian crisis​


Nir (Shoko) Cohen|05.05.24 | 06:22

Benjamin Netanyahu
Hamas atrocities
Mossad

Qatar

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu urged the government of Qatar to continue the transfer of money to Gaza, in a secret letter sent to the Qatari leadership in 2018 and only seen by a handful of people since. In the letter, Netanyahu explained that the funding would reduce the motivation of terror groups there to carry out attacks, would prevent a humanitarian crisis and was vital for preserving regional stability.

There are two different time periods for Qatari funding of the Gaza Strip, which allowed Hamas to grow from an insignificant terror organization into a military empire with battalions, an underground network of tunnels and the fire power of a small army.

3 View gallery

יחיא סינוואר, מוחמד בן עבד א-רחמן אאל ת'אני, בנימין נתניהו

Benjamin Netanyahu, Sheikh Mohammed Thani , Yahya Sinwar

(Photo: Dana Kopel , Mark Schiefelbein/ Reuters, Reuters)

Between 2007 and 2014, Qatar provided Hamas with funds, away from any international oversight or review and from 2014 on, funding from Qatar was coordinated with the United States and Israel.

The 2014 war in Gaza was the turning point. The U.S., UN, Israel and Qatar decided soon after the war to set up a new system in which $30 million would be delivered to the coastal strip by Doha each month. Some $10 million was to buy fuel from Israel, needed to operate Gaza's power station, $10 million to pay the salaries of government employees, and the final $10 million was to be given in $100 stipends to some 100,000 Gazan families in need.

That was the time when the notion that Hamas would back away from its intent to destroy Israel as long as it accumulates governing and economic assets took root in Israel.

Until 2018, Qatari funds were not given to Gaza on a regular basis and delivered only occasionally with approval from Israel and the Palestinian Authority. "The PA said it would no longer agree to fund Hamas and rather than let the terror group collapse, Israel decided on an alternative route for its funding," says Dr. Udi Levi, who was the Mossad official charged with fighting the funding of terror until 2016. "That was part of Israel's policy to buy quiet. Hamas demanded that the $30 million per month would be delivered directly to the ruling faction. It was naïve to believe Hamas would provide the money to the population in Gaza."

תיעוד: חשיפת מנהרת הטרור הגדולה ביותר ברצועת עזה

IDF soldier in a massive Hamas tunnel uncovered in northern Gaza

(Photo: IDF)

It is now evident that Qatar was not fond of the new arrangement. "They were playing a double game then and are still doing so now," Levi says. "We are talking about the greatest funder of terrorism in the world, but in 2018 Qatar was concerned that funding Hamas – which had been designated a terror organization – would create problems with international institutions."

Meanwhile, in November of 2018, then-Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman resigned in protest against the government over a cease-fire in Gaza. "We are on one hand passing a law to withhold funds from the PA, for funding terrorists and on the other hand allowing funds to flow to the terrorists in Gaza," Liberman said. Anyone who says there is oversight of where those funds go, is being inaccurate, to put it mildly."

Netanyahu understood the Qatari predicament and sent his urgent letter to Doha but the officials there demanded further assurances. "There was a sense that the Americans were needed, in order to seal the deal," Levi says.

Then-U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Steve Mnuchin, who was in charge of finance for the campaign to reelect Donald Trump and who is Jewish, agreed to a request from Netanyahu and sent an additional letter to Doha, this time from Washington, in effect, ensuring Qatar that the funding of Hamas would not be considered funding terror.

Levi explains that, although he had run the financial war on funding of terrorism between 2001 and 2016, he was never consulted by the political leadership about the transfer of funds to Hamas. "Unlike previous administrations I have served under, during the governments of [Ariel] Sharon and [Ehud] Olmert, Netanyahu did not consult with me despite the fact that I served directly under him," he says. "I, of course, strongly objected to the transfer of Qatari funding to Hamas, even before 2018, but that did not interest Netanyahu."

yk13881624

Then-US Secretary of the Treasury Steve Mnuchin with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu

(Photo: Emile Salman)

Ultimately the letters from Netanyahu and Mnuchin satisfied the Qataris and the first instalment in cash was delivered on November 8, 2014, and the rest is history that is still unfolding.

The Prime Minister's Office did not respond to a request for comment on this topic.
 

nyknick

refuel w/ chocolate milk
Joined
Jul 7, 2012
Messages
18,714
Reputation
6,060
Daps
90,732
I honestly don't think so, there is an almost unparalleled amount of disinformation and psychological warfare taking place

We should all have a hard time taking leaks about the negotiations that are taking place at face value until something is agreed to

I have no doubt that Netanyahu and Hamas leadership are exploiting the situation to their maximum personal benefit
Suggesting that families of hostages are spreading disinformation and doing psychological warfare that helps Hamas is pretty disgusting for a guy that constantly posts "free hostages".

But since you're one of the few that gives a damn about hostages I guess you also care more than their families.
 

88m3

Fast Money & Foreign Objects
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
88,173
Reputation
3,616
Daps
157,198
Reppin
Brooklyn
Suggesting that families of hostages are spreading disinformation and doing psychological warfare that helps Hamas is pretty disgusting for a guy that constantly posts "free hostages".

But since you're one of the few that gives a damn about hostages I guess you also care more than their families.

Yup, that's exactly what I said

:laff:
 

nyknick

refuel w/ chocolate milk
Joined
Jul 7, 2012
Messages
18,714
Reputation
6,060
Daps
90,732
Yup, that's exactly what I said

:laff:
You responded to an interview from ex-spokesperson of Families Forum and families themselves still protesting talking about unparalleled amount of disinformation and psychological warfare.

I don't know who else you could be talking about. Please enlighten me.
 

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,587
Reputation
5,962
Daps
165,178
But since you're one of the few that gives a damn about hostages I guess you also care more than their families.
you know that sociopathic poster truly believes he cares more about the hostages.
 

nyknick

refuel w/ chocolate milk
Joined
Jul 7, 2012
Messages
18,714
Reputation
6,060
Daps
90,732
you know that sociopathic poster truly believes he cares more about the hostages.
I doubt it, even if he was that delusional at least it would be respectable to some extent. I feel like he's just using them as props just like Israeli government.

In the middle of posts about starving children, ICC plans to issue warrants, human rights violations, Israel's refusal for cease fire (all from respectable news sources) he drops in with a "but hostages" post and gets into a nonsensical back and forth with anyone that engages.
 
Top