WR Kadarius Toney to the Chiefs
Kansas City Chiefs got: ToneyNew York Giants got: 2023 third-round pick; 2023 sixth-round pick
Trade date: Oct. 27
Original grade for the Chiefs: B
New grade for the Chiefs: C
When you think of Toney as a member of the Chiefs, you think of Super Bowl LVII heroics, when he had a go-ahead touchdown in the fourth quarter and a 65-yard punt return to put Kansas City at the 5-yard line a few minutes later. He also played just six offensive snaps in that game.
That's the thing with Toney: He has tantalizing promise, but the results haven't matched up. He totaled 221 receiving yards over 10 regular and postseason games last season and has just 83 in five games this season. He had a brutal drop-filled Week 1 -- including one that resulted in a pick-six -- in the Chiefs' loss to the Lions. He has played in just 23% of Kansas City's offensive snaps this season, same as last regular season post-trade.
The Chiefs have him on an inexpensive contract this season and next, and there's always a chance he can put it together; he's still just 24, after all. But so far, while he has had a couple of very high-profile successes, the results overall have been lackluster.
Original grade for the Giants: B
New grade for the Giants: A
Sometimes unloading a contract at a low price is the right thing to do. Just 1½ years after drafting him in the first round, the Giants dealt Toney for a third-round pick and a sixth-round pick after he'd been on the field for 12 games for them. They're probably happy about how it all turned out.
While the Giants still have a weakness at wide receiver, what they really need is an outside receiving threat -- an entirely different skill set from Toney's. The draft compensation was worth more to the Giants.
WR Robbie Chosen to the Cardinals
Arizona Cardinals got: ChosenCarolina Panthers got: Sixth-round pick in 2024, seventh-round pick in 2025
Trade date: Oct. 17
Original grade for the Cardinals: C
New grade for the Cardinals: D
Chosen's lack of production for the Cardinals -- he caught seven passes for 76 yards -- was foreseeable. At the time of this trade, I noted that Anderson had been the worst qualifying wideout in the Receiver Tracking Metrics in 2021, was below average at that point in 2022 and had an incredibly poor 48% catch rate to that point. Arizona was taking a low-risk swing at what they hoped was a useful rental receiver, but the chances were very low, and they did not pan out.
A year later, it's wild to think of Arizona acquiring a player at the trade deadline, albeit on an affordable deal. It is the small price paid for the contract that prevents this grade from being an F. Otherwise, nothing about this deal worked in the Cardinals' favor.
Original grade for the Panthers: B+
New grade for the Panthers: B+
Carolina did well in getting a couple of late-round draft picks for Chosen instead of holding on to him for nothing. His dead cap money was a sunk cost, and there was no way the Panthers (or any others) were going to keep him on the contract he was on -- which included a non-guaranteed $12 million in 2024 -- beyond 2023. It was a home run in terms of execution, and I only give it a B+ because the scale of draft picks was so small.