McShay and Kiper 2 round dueling mock.
Round 1
1. Cleveland Browns
Kiper: Myles Garrett, DE, Texas A&M | Watch highlights
No change at the top. Garrett is the best pass-rusher in a class full of them. He's a rare talent and a physical freak (4.64 40-yard dash and 41-inch vertical at 6-foot-4, 272 pounds), and he also produces on the field (32.5 sacks in three seasons).
McShay: Myles Garrett, DE, Texas A&M | Watch highlights
Yeah, there's no reason to overthink this, Cleveland. Take the clear-cut best player in this draft.
2. San Francisco 49ers
Kiper: Solomon Thomas, DE, Stanford | Watch highlights
I think San Francisco will wait on a quarterback (maybe Kirk Cousins in 2018?). Outside of the Browns, the 49ers have the worst talent on their roster from top to bottom, and picking Thomas would beef up their defense. He's a different player than the D-linemen the 49ers have taken in the first round the past two years (DeForest Buckner and Arik Armstead) and has double-digit sack potential.
McShay: Solomon Thomas, DE, Stanford | Watch highlights
The 49ers don't necessarily need to force it and spend the No. 2 pick on a QB after picking up Brian Hoyer and Matt Barkley in free agency. What they need is more impact players, and Thomas is the total package off the edge, with size, quickness and power.
3. Chicago Bears
Kiper: Malik Hooker, S, Ohio State | Watch highlights
Safety is a clear need. I had gone with Jamal Adams here, but Hooker is more of a center fielder-type with deep range and great speed. He has some Ed Reed in him as a playmaker. In his first season as a starter, he had seven interceptions in 2016, including three pick-sixes.
McShay: Jonathan Allen, DL, Alabama | Watch highlights
Stick with the tape on Allen. He's still our No. 2 overall player, even after mediocre workouts. Allen's quickness and power help him constantly push the pocket as a pass-rusher, and he had 22.5 sacks in the past two seasons. The Bears could use a solidifying force along the interior.
4. Jacksonville Jaguars
Kiper: Jonathan Allen, DL, Alabama | Watch highlights
The Jaguars are trying to be competitive, and I don't think they're giving up on Blake Bortles yet. And Todd's absolutely right about Allen, who would probably slot in at defensive tackle next to 2016 big-money signing Malik Jackson. Let Allen get after quarterbacks and disrupt running games.
McShay: Leonard Fournette, RB, LSU | Watch highlights
The Jaguars could easily go with LSU safety Jamal Adams here, but they've spent loads of draft capital and free-agent money on their defense in recent years and need more offensive playmakers. Enter Fournette, who would give Jacksonville instant stability at running back. He has a rare combination of size (240 pounds), speed (4.51 40) and power.
5. Tennessee Titans (from Rams)
Kiper: Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio State | Watch highlights
The Titans would probably be thrilled at the chance to pick the draft's No. 1 corner. Lattimore is an athletic phenom who doesn't have a ton of experience. He ran a 4.36 40 and had a 38½-inch vertical at the combine, but he started just one season for the Buckeyes. This could be a spot where a team like Cleveland tries to trade up to take the top quarterback.
McShay: Malik Hooker, S, Ohio State | Watch highlights
I'll go with a different Buckeyes defensive back. Tennessee added Johnathan Cyprien in free agency, but he's more of a run-stuffer. Hooker can provide the speed, range and elite ball skills the Titans need in the deep middle of the field. I also wouldn't completely rule out LB Haason Reddikk with this pick. There's a growing sentiment that he'll be off the board by the time Tennessee picks again in Round 1 at No. 18 overall.
6. New York Jets
Kiper: Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina | Watch highlights
Another quarterback for the Jets, you ask? Well, why not? Trubisky is my No. 1 signal-caller, and they've already worked him out privately. Josh McCown is far from the long-term answer, and Christian Hackenberg, a second-round pick in 2016, couldn't get on the field last season. Trubisky has a high ceiling, but he has been a starter for only one year.
McShay: Jamal Adams, S, LSU | Watch highlights
There's a lot of buzz about QBs Deshaun Watson or Mitch Trubisky with this pick, and I see that Mel has hopped on that bandwagon. But it'd be really tough for the Jets to pass up Adams if he's still on the board here. A big hitter with excellent intangibles, Adams is one of the few players with an elite grade in this year's class.
7. Los Angeles Chargers
Kiper: Jamal Adams, S, LSU | Watch highlights
Adams is a steal if he falls in this range, like Todd says, and the Chargers could use him in a variety of roles -- playing in the box, covering tight ends and slot receivers, and disguising him on blitzes. New defensive coordinator Gus Bradley can get creative in finding ways to play Adams and Jahleel Addae on all three downs.
McShay: Deshaun Watson, QB, Clemson | Watch highlights
Do the Chargers have bigger needs? Yes. But this move would be about giving coach Anthony Lynn a clear succession plan at quarterback for Philip Rivers. Watson has the kind of makeup to overcome his weaknesses, particularly if he lands with a team determined to keep him on the sideline early in his career (like the Chargers).
8. Carolina Panthers
Kiper: Leonard Fournette, RB, LSU | Watch highlights
Carolina is really the first logical spot I see for a running back, unless a team trades up. Fournette is a special player who has looked like a first-round pick since he stepped on the field at LSU. The Panthers need a successor to Jonathan Stewart, who turned 30 in March.
McShay: Derek Barnett, DE, Tennessee | Watch highlights
The Panthers' three main edge rushers -- Julius Peppers, Charles Johnson and Mario Addison -- will be 37, 31 and 30 years old at the start of next season. In other words, Carolina needs to find a younger player who can get after the QB. Barnett has some of the most impressive production of any pass-rusher in this class, considering the competition he played against (42 tackles for loss and 29 sacks vs. the SEC in three seasons).
9. Cincinnati Bengals
Kiper: Mike Williams, WR, Clemson | Watch highlights
The Bengals' offense didn't look the same after losing Mohamed Sanu and Marvin Jones in free agency last year. With Williams (98 catches for 1,361 yards and 11 touchdowns for the national champs last season) and A.J. Green, Cincinnati would have one of the best receiving tandems in the league. Last year's second-round pick, Tyler Boyd, was just OK in 2016 (54 catches, 603 yards), and veteran Brandon LaFell is slotted in as the other starter.
McShay: Corey Davis, WR, Western Michigan | Watch highlights
Agree on the position, but not the pick, Kiper. If the board falls this way, the Bengals will be in a tough spot. Davis and Williams would both be slight reaches; same with UCLA pass-rusher Takkarist McKinley. Davis' size (6-2, 205), ball skills and speed (estimated in the 4.4s, based on tape) make him a Day 1 NFL starter outside the numbers.
10. Buffalo Bills
Kiper: O.J. Howard, TE, Alabama | Watch highlights
Buffalo badly needs pass-catchers, and Howard is the best tight end in the draft. He has all of the athletic attributes (4.51 40 at 6-6, 251) of a top-tier all-around player. Charles Clay has underperformed the five-year deal he signed in 2015.
McShay: Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio State | Watch highlights
If Lattimore fell this far, his history of hamstring injuries would probably be the biggest reason. Durability issues aside, the Bills would be thrilled to see Lattimore available here. He has elite coverage ability and good ball skills. Plus, cornerback is suddenly a much bigger need in Buffalo after it lost Stephon Gilmore in free agency.
1. Cleveland Browns
Kiper: Myles Garrett, DE, Texas A&M | Watch highlights
No change at the top. Garrett is the best pass-rusher in a class full of them. He's a rare talent and a physical freak (4.64 40-yard dash and 41-inch vertical at 6-foot-4, 272 pounds), and he also produces on the field (32.5 sacks in three seasons).
McShay: Myles Garrett, DE, Texas A&M | Watch highlights
Yeah, there's no reason to overthink this, Cleveland. Take the clear-cut best player in this draft.
2. San Francisco 49ers
Kiper: Solomon Thomas, DE, Stanford | Watch highlights
I think San Francisco will wait on a quarterback (maybe Kirk Cousins in 2018?). Outside of the Browns, the 49ers have the worst talent on their roster from top to bottom, and picking Thomas would beef up their defense. He's a different player than the D-linemen the 49ers have taken in the first round the past two years (DeForest Buckner and Arik Armstead) and has double-digit sack potential.
McShay: Solomon Thomas, DE, Stanford | Watch highlights
The 49ers don't necessarily need to force it and spend the No. 2 pick on a QB after picking up Brian Hoyer and Matt Barkley in free agency. What they need is more impact players, and Thomas is the total package off the edge, with size, quickness and power.
3. Chicago Bears
Kiper: Malik Hooker, S, Ohio State | Watch highlights
Safety is a clear need. I had gone with Jamal Adams here, but Hooker is more of a center fielder-type with deep range and great speed. He has some Ed Reed in him as a playmaker. In his first season as a starter, he had seven interceptions in 2016, including three pick-sixes.
McShay: Jonathan Allen, DL, Alabama | Watch highlights
Stick with the tape on Allen. He's still our No. 2 overall player, even after mediocre workouts. Allen's quickness and power help him constantly push the pocket as a pass-rusher, and he had 22.5 sacks in the past two seasons. The Bears could use a solidifying force along the interior.
4. Jacksonville Jaguars
Kiper: Jonathan Allen, DL, Alabama | Watch highlights
The Jaguars are trying to be competitive, and I don't think they're giving up on Blake Bortles yet. And Todd's absolutely right about Allen, who would probably slot in at defensive tackle next to 2016 big-money signing Malik Jackson. Let Allen get after quarterbacks and disrupt running games.
McShay: Leonard Fournette, RB, LSU | Watch highlights
The Jaguars could easily go with LSU safety Jamal Adams here, but they've spent loads of draft capital and free-agent money on their defense in recent years and need more offensive playmakers. Enter Fournette, who would give Jacksonville instant stability at running back. He has a rare combination of size (240 pounds), speed (4.51 40) and power.
5. Tennessee Titans (from Rams)
Kiper: Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio State | Watch highlights
The Titans would probably be thrilled at the chance to pick the draft's No. 1 corner. Lattimore is an athletic phenom who doesn't have a ton of experience. He ran a 4.36 40 and had a 38½-inch vertical at the combine, but he started just one season for the Buckeyes. This could be a spot where a team like Cleveland tries to trade up to take the top quarterback.
McShay: Malik Hooker, S, Ohio State | Watch highlights
I'll go with a different Buckeyes defensive back. Tennessee added Johnathan Cyprien in free agency, but he's more of a run-stuffer. Hooker can provide the speed, range and elite ball skills the Titans need in the deep middle of the field. I also wouldn't completely rule out LB Haason Reddikk with this pick. There's a growing sentiment that he'll be off the board by the time Tennessee picks again in Round 1 at No. 18 overall.
6. New York Jets
Kiper: Mitch Trubisky, QB, North Carolina | Watch highlights
Another quarterback for the Jets, you ask? Well, why not? Trubisky is my No. 1 signal-caller, and they've already worked him out privately. Josh McCown is far from the long-term answer, and Christian Hackenberg, a second-round pick in 2016, couldn't get on the field last season. Trubisky has a high ceiling, but he has been a starter for only one year.
McShay: Jamal Adams, S, LSU | Watch highlights
There's a lot of buzz about QBs Deshaun Watson or Mitch Trubisky with this pick, and I see that Mel has hopped on that bandwagon. But it'd be really tough for the Jets to pass up Adams if he's still on the board here. A big hitter with excellent intangibles, Adams is one of the few players with an elite grade in this year's class.
7. Los Angeles Chargers
Kiper: Jamal Adams, S, LSU | Watch highlights
Adams is a steal if he falls in this range, like Todd says, and the Chargers could use him in a variety of roles -- playing in the box, covering tight ends and slot receivers, and disguising him on blitzes. New defensive coordinator Gus Bradley can get creative in finding ways to play Adams and Jahleel Addae on all three downs.
McShay: Deshaun Watson, QB, Clemson | Watch highlights
Do the Chargers have bigger needs? Yes. But this move would be about giving coach Anthony Lynn a clear succession plan at quarterback for Philip Rivers. Watson has the kind of makeup to overcome his weaknesses, particularly if he lands with a team determined to keep him on the sideline early in his career (like the Chargers).
8. Carolina Panthers
Kiper: Leonard Fournette, RB, LSU | Watch highlights
Carolina is really the first logical spot I see for a running back, unless a team trades up. Fournette is a special player who has looked like a first-round pick since he stepped on the field at LSU. The Panthers need a successor to Jonathan Stewart, who turned 30 in March.
McShay: Derek Barnett, DE, Tennessee | Watch highlights
The Panthers' three main edge rushers -- Julius Peppers, Charles Johnson and Mario Addison -- will be 37, 31 and 30 years old at the start of next season. In other words, Carolina needs to find a younger player who can get after the QB. Barnett has some of the most impressive production of any pass-rusher in this class, considering the competition he played against (42 tackles for loss and 29 sacks vs. the SEC in three seasons).
9. Cincinnati Bengals
Kiper: Mike Williams, WR, Clemson | Watch highlights
The Bengals' offense didn't look the same after losing Mohamed Sanu and Marvin Jones in free agency last year. With Williams (98 catches for 1,361 yards and 11 touchdowns for the national champs last season) and A.J. Green, Cincinnati would have one of the best receiving tandems in the league. Last year's second-round pick, Tyler Boyd, was just OK in 2016 (54 catches, 603 yards), and veteran Brandon LaFell is slotted in as the other starter.
McShay: Corey Davis, WR, Western Michigan | Watch highlights
Agree on the position, but not the pick, Kiper. If the board falls this way, the Bengals will be in a tough spot. Davis and Williams would both be slight reaches; same with UCLA pass-rusher Takkarist McKinley. Davis' size (6-2, 205), ball skills and speed (estimated in the 4.4s, based on tape) make him a Day 1 NFL starter outside the numbers.
10. Buffalo Bills
Kiper: O.J. Howard, TE, Alabama | Watch highlights
Buffalo badly needs pass-catchers, and Howard is the best tight end in the draft. He has all of the athletic attributes (4.51 40 at 6-6, 251) of a top-tier all-around player. Charles Clay has underperformed the five-year deal he signed in 2015.
McShay: Marshon Lattimore, CB, Ohio State | Watch highlights
If Lattimore fell this far, his history of hamstring injuries would probably be the biggest reason. Durability issues aside, the Bills would be thrilled to see Lattimore available here. He has elite coverage ability and good ball skills. Plus, cornerback is suddenly a much bigger need in Buffalo after it lost Stephon Gilmore in free agency.
Last edited: