The irony of all this is that Triple Haitch is actually a B+ player

Buggsy Mogues

My spot is solidified if you ask me
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
15,260
Reputation
3,659
Daps
80,044
Reppin
City of Angels :blessed:
But Rock outdrew Austin in 2000 without his involvement. Thats where you dudes get confused and what I keep stressing. You guys think Macho/Hogan is comparabe to Rock/Austin when its not the case. It was Hogan then everyone else. And fukk that its not fair to penalize someone for drawing with someone shyt. Because the most popular criticism of HHH is he was just the guy who worked with the main draw. Well the same can be said for Savage. His second reign he did jack shyt. Didn't even main event PPVs. And he was thought so little of that he regulated to color commentator duty with the occasional match against Doink:mjlmao:

CHURCH
 

AKM-95

All Star
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
2,345
Reputation
575
Daps
5,570
Reppin
Parts Unknown
:beli: @ the idea that HHH only has ONE classic match


I'm not going to front that's not true but allot of his stuff runs together to me :yeshrug:


HHH is a legend but he 's not in the league of Flair, Hogan, Rocky, Savage, ,or Austin those guys star power, and or ring ability made them true legends.

he's is in the Bret Hart, John Cena, Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, level guy too me. Those Guys have drawling power but have limited crossover appeal.
 

Buggsy Mogues

My spot is solidified if you ask me
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
15,260
Reputation
3,659
Daps
80,044
Reppin
City of Angels :blessed:
You're telling me that man who headed a stable and was top face/heel at the same time and was so over that they made a ppv in his own backyard for this feud named after his family's wrestling promotion was not a major draw? If he was not a major draw, then they wouldn't give his guys the reigns or go to Canada.

he was the top draw at that time...but that's like saying he was the shiniest piece of shyt. WWF damn near ran itself out of business at that time cause their ratings/attendance/ppv's were so bad in the bret/HBK era.

The Canada thing is irrelevant -- that's his hometown and his whole gimmick was pro Canada/anti-America. The fact that they did the show there doesnt prove anything other than that he was a big draw in his hometown.
 

dh86

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
23,838
Reputation
950
Daps
53,888
Reppin
Detroit
But Rock outdrew Austin in 2000 without his involvement. Thats where you dudes get confused and what I keep stressing. You guys think Macho/Hogan is comparabe to Rock/Austin when its not the case. It was Hogan then everyone else. And fukk that its not fair to penalize someone for drawing with someone shyt. Because the most popular criticism of HHH is he was just the guy who worked with the main draw. Well the same can be said for Savage. His second reign he did jack shyt. Didn't even main event PPVs. And he was thought so little of that he regulated to color commentator duty with the occasional match against Doink:mjlmao:

Macho Man was sent to commentary because he was he was 40. Around that time, Vince purged the roster of the 80s guys and Hogan was going to be phased out and into the 'Bruno role' too. The entire reason Hulk went to WCW. Randy Savage and HHH are two different levels, I thought the publicity Savage's death got taught you this. Do you understand what 650,000 ppv buys for Mania 5 in 1989 entails? The number of homes with cable in 1989 are a fraction of today yet that 650k isn't too far off from recent Mania's domestic buys. A number like that means there were two draws.
 

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
66,303
Reputation
13,197
Daps
92,629
Reppin
CHICAGO
Rock Ladder match Summerslam 98

3 stages of hell HBK

No holds barred match vs Cactus Jack

2nd Mania match against Undertaker

So yes he does


hell in a cell vs cactus jack
last man standing vs Jericho
iron man vs rock
three stages of hell versus Austin
triple threat vs hbk vs benoit

two man power trip vs benoit/Jericho :
I know he was on the floor, but still...it is a classic match.



art barr
 
Last edited:

Art Barr

INVADING SOHH CHAMPION
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
66,303
Reputation
13,197
Daps
92,629
Reppin
CHICAGO
I swear the macho man/sting legacy overrating has got to stop. Sting only drew when matched against the right guy (flair late 80s/Hogan 97). And Savage was always overshadowed by Hogan/Warrior during the height of his drawing power


that is because the booking was not aligned with savage or sting in that time period.
you are stating this from a mark's perspective.

art barr
 

R=G

Street Terrorist
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
123,915
Reputation
8,613
Daps
146,529
Reppin
Westcoast
You're telling me that man who headed a stable and was top face/heel at the same time and was so over that they made a ppv in his own backyard for this feud named after his family's wrestling promotion was not a major draw? If he was not a major draw, then they wouldn't give his guys the reigns or go to Canada.
he was the top draw at that time...but that's like saying he was the shiniest piece of shyt. WWF damn near ran itself out of business at that time cause their ratings/attendance/ppv's were so bad in the bret/HBK era.

The Canada thing is irrelevant -- that's his hometown and his whole gimmick was pro Canada/anti-America. The fact that they did the show there doesnt prove anything other than that he was a big draw in his hometown.
hell in a cell vs cactus jack
last man standing vs Jericho
iron man vs rock
three stages of hell versus Austin
triple threat vs hbk vs benoit

two man power trip vs benoit/Jericho :
I know he was on the floor, but still...it is a classic match.



art barr

Classic yet the E acts like most those matches never existed. And if they can't credit any of Macho ' s work, then nothing Cripple H has done has ever mattered.
 

FreshAIG

Moderator
Staff member
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
70,070
Reputation
15,603
Daps
308,103
Reppin
Californ-i-a by way of BK
But Rock outdrew Austin in 2000 without his involvement. Thats where you dudes get confused and what I keep stressing. You guys think Macho/Hogan is comparabe to Rock/Austin when its not the case. It was Hogan then everyone else. And fukk that its not fair to penalize someone for drawing with someone shyt. Because the most popular criticism of HHH is he was just the guy who worked with the main draw. Well the same can be said for Savage. His second reign he did jack shyt. Didn't even main event PPVs. And he was thought so little of that he regulated to color commentator duty with the occasional match against Doink:mjlmao:

No it was not "Hogan then everyone else" because if that was the case, Hogan would have drawn big with everyone he faced and everywhere he wrestled. He didn't. If Hogan didn't have a good antagonist he didn't draw that well (He never drew when he faced Hennig, Rude, or anyone significantly smaller than him except for when he fought, ding ding you guessed it, Randy Savage, Piper and Orndorff) , and in certain places Piper drew more than Hogan.

Savage and Hogan did better business than any of Hogan's other opponents for a reason. You think you replace Savage in those matches with anyone else they're doing that kinda business? Not a chance. They did 650k buys in 1989, when only 7 million homes had PPV access. Do you understand how insane that is? If they kept that same percentage with the amount of homes that carry PPV now, do you understand how many buys that would be? We're talking astronomical through the roof numbers.

And come on man, the business was in the shyts back 1992. Nobody could draw in that era. Hogan left because his drawing power was all but gone at that point, WWF was facing the big steroid scandal. It was a terrible time. But look at Savage as a draw in his WCW years. He did pretty good and him and Flair's feud was pumping back up WCW's business in the beginning of 1996 before the nWo came and Hogan was mostly gone. 7 years in his career Savage was a top 10 draw. 2 of the years he was top 2, and 3 of the years he was top 5. That's incredible.

The problem with your Triple H/Savage comparison is nobody is saying Savage is Hogan, The Rock, Austin as a draw. We're saying he was a great antagonist. HHH was a great antaganoist for The Rock. You replace HHH with say Ken Shamrock or the Big Bossman in 2000, and the Rock isn't breaking any records. People criticize Triple H's drawing power when people compare him to Austin, the Rock and so on. We're not comparing Savage to the A+ guys, just the A guys.

And no that last sentence has to be trolling. Vince was trying to get Savage back in the ring during that period whenever he could to pop business a little.
 

The G.O.D II

A ha ha
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
86,406
Reputation
4,924
Daps
190,588
I'm not reading this long diatribe above me completely. But just the fact I see Hogan name dozens of time proves my point. HE ONLY DREW with HOGAN. NOT FLAIR. NOT WARRIOR. Same with Sting who only drew with flair or hogan. These guys were not top flight level guys. Why is that so hard to understand?
 

Kevin_Nash

2x WWE Hall of Famer
Joined
Dec 9, 2013
Messages
525
Reputation
625
Daps
3,635


Until I see any of these "A+" players survive a war like the one I survived in this Gauntlet Match, I'm the only "A+" player pal. Like my buddy 2pac once said, All Eyes we On Me anytime I was on TV.
 

dh86

Superstar
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
23,838
Reputation
950
Daps
53,888
Reppin
Detroit
Since you came at me talking so sideways with that disrespectful ass tone, I took the liberty of actually taking the time out of my day and introducing some COLD HARD FACTS into this discussion. I went back on the history of WWE website and looked at live attendance figures for the shows Savage headlined during his 89-90 run, versus shows Warrior headlined during his 89-90 run. These are only shows that DID NOT INCLUDE HULK HOGAN on the card.

WINNPIEG:

SAVAGE:

WWF @ Winnipeg, Manitoba - Arena - January 21, 1988 (2,500)
WWF @ Winnipeg, Manitoba - Arena - May 12, 1988 (4,000)
WWF @ Winnipeg, Manitoba - Arena - February 27, 1989 (4,500)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Winnipeg, Manitoba - Arena - August 17, 1990 (4,000)

Advantage: Randy Savage



SPRINGFIELD, MA
SAVAGE:
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - April 22, 1988 (9,000)**
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - August 5, 1988 (2,700)
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - November 6, 1988 (3,100)
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - December 4, 1988 (2,700)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - March 17, 1990 (matinee) (4,800)
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - August 7, 1990 (300 shy of a sell out)**
WWF @ Springfield, MA - Civic Center - December 26, 1990 (matinee) (4,200)


Advantage: Warrior

PROVIDENCE, RI


SAVAGE:
WWF @ Providence, RI - Civic Center - April 23, 1988 (6,700)
WWF @ Providence, RI - Civic Center - May 28, 1988 (5,400)
WWF @ Providence, RI - Civic Center - August 23, 1988 (13,800; sell out)**
King of the Ring 88 - Providence, RI - Civic Center - October 16, 1988 (6,700)
WWF @ Providence, RI - Civic Center - December 2, 1988 (5,000)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Providence, RI - Civic Center - April 21, 1990 (4,700)
WWF @ Providence, RI - Civic Center - November 21, 1990 (4,500)


Advantage: Savage

LANDOVER, MD


SAVAGE:
WWF @ Landover, MD - Capital Centre - April 24, 1988 (4,500)
WWF @ Landover, MD - Capital Centre - July 16, 1988 (9,000)
WWF @ Landover, MD - Capital Centre - October 15, 1988 (2,800)
WWF @ Landover, MD - Capital Centre - November 20, 1988 (2,500)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Landover, MD - Capital Centre - September 14, 1990 (6,500)


Advantage: Savage

MADISON SQUARE GARDEN

SAVAGE:
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - April 25, 1988 (17,000)**
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - May 27, 1988 (16,000)**
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - June 25, 1988 (18,300)**
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - September 29, 1988 (13,500)**
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - October 24, 1988 (12,500)**
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - December 30, 1988 (16,000)**


WARRIOR:
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - September 30, 1989 (20,000; sell out)
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - October 28, 1989 (16,000)**
WWF @ New York City, NY - Madison Square Garden - September 21, 1990 (11,000+)


Advantage: Warrior


LOS ANGELES, CA

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Los Angeles, CA - Sports Arena - May 1, 1988 (13,000)
WWF @ Los Angeles, CA - Sports Arena - June 4, 1988 (10,000)
WWF @ Los Angeles, CA - Sports Arena - September 17, 1988 (12,500)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Los Angeles, CA - Sports Arena - January 26, 1990 (12,000)
WWF @ Los Angeles, CA - Sports Arena - July 27, 1990 (11,700)
WWF @ Los Angeles, CA - Sports Arena - March 25, 1990 (matinee) (11,000)


Advantage: Savage barely


OMAHA, NE

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Omaha, NE - Civic Auditorium - May 13, 1988 (7,280)
WWF @ Omaha, NE - Civic Auditorium - October 2, 1988 (8,484)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Omaha, NE - Civic Auditorium - February 27, 1990 (5,998)
WWF @ Omaha, NE - Civic Auditorium - July 16, 1990 (10,303; sell out)**
WWF @ Omaha, NE - Civic Auditorium - October 6, 1990 (4,500)

Advantage: Warrior

CHICAGO

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Chicago, IL - Rosemont Horizon - May 15, 1988 (8,500)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Chicago, IL - Rosemont Horizon - June 23, 1990 (7,100)
WWF @ Chicago, IL - Rosemont Horizon - September 16, 1990 (6,400)
WWF @ Chicago, IL - Rosemont Horizon - December 29, 1990 (10,600)

Advantage: Warrior



ST. LOUIS

SAVAGE:
WWF @ St. Louis, MO - Kiel Auditorium - May 20, 1988 (3,700)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ St. Louis, MO - Arena - June 22, 1990 (4,700)
WWF @ St. Louis, MO - Arena - October 5, 1990 (5,000)

Advantage: Warrior

DENVER

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Denver, CO - Auditorium - May 22, 1988 (8,500)
WWF @ Denver, CO - Auditorium - September 30, 1988 (6,500)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Denver, CO - Coliseum - June 28, 1990 (6,400)
WWF @ Denver, CO - Coliseum - September 1, 1990 (5,800)

Advantage: Savage



FRESNO

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Fresno, CA - Convention Center - May 31, 1988 (7,000)**

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Fresno, CA - Selland Arena - July 18, 1990 (4,500)

Advantage: Savage



OAKLAND

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Oakland, CA - Coliseum - June 1, 1988 (12,120; 9,000 paid)**
WWF @ Oakland, CA - Coliseum - August 12, 1988 (10,500 paid)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Oakland, CA - Coliseum - July 28, 1990 (12,000)

Advantage: Savage

TACOMA

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Tacoma, WA - Tacoma Dome - June 3, 1988 (11,000)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Tacoma, WA - Tacoma Dome - July 9, 1990 (4,000)

Advantage: Savage



PITTSBURGH

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Pittsburgh, PA - Civic Arena - June 10, 1988 (4,734)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Pittsburgh, PA - Civic Arena - June 9, 1990 (about 11,000 paid)
Advantage: Warrior

UTICA, NY


SAVAGE:
WWF @ Utica, NY - Memorial Auditorium - June 23, 1988 (3,453)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Utica, NY - Memorial Auditorium - August 15, 1990 (5,000; sell out)**

Advantage: Warrior



Richmond, VA

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Richmond, VA - Coliseum - June 24, 1988 (7,000)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Richmond, VA - Coliseum - June 29, 1990 (4,600)

Advantage: Savage

TOLEDO

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Toledo, OH - Sports Arena - July 7, 1988 (3,500)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Toledo, OH - Sports Arena - June 10, 1990 (4,500)

Advantage: Warrior

BOSTON

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - October 10, 1988 (5,000)**
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - November 5, 1988 (6,500)**
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - July 9, 1988 (5,000)**
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - August 6, 1988 (8,000)**

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - January 13, 1990 (announced at 9,200)
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - March 17, 1990 (7,500)
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - June 2, 1990 (6,000)
WWF @ Boston, MA - Boston Garden - September 15, 1990 (6,000)


Advantage: Warrior


PHILADELPHIA

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - July 23, 1988 (9,115)**
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - August 27, 1988 (4,418)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - September 24, 1988 (3,952)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - December 17, 1988 (matinee) (5,723)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - January 14, 1989 (matinee) (6,018)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - January 20, 1990 (matinee) (8,216)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - April 28, 1990 (6,549)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - October 20, 1990 (5,500)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - November 17, 1990 (9,400)
WWF @ Philadelphia, PA - Spectrum - December 15, 1990 (6,012)


Advantage: Warrior

HARTFORD


SAVAGE:
WWF @ Hartford, CT - Civic Center - August 24, 1988 (16,000; sell out)**
WWF @ Hartford, CT - Civic Center - December 31, 1988 (6,700)

WARRIOR:
WWF @ Hartford, CT - Civic Center - May 17, 1990 (6,000)


Advantage: Savage


ROCHESTER

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Rochester, NY - War Memorial - November 27, 1988 (4,000)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Rochester, NY - War Memorial Auditorium - June 5, 1990 (8,000)

Advantage: Warrior



SAVAGE:
WWF @ Utica, NY - February 12, 1989 (5,000; sell out)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Utica, NY - Memorial Auditorium - August 15, 1990 (5,000; sell out)
NEW MEXICO

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Albuquerque, NM - March 6, 1989 (3,602)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Albuquerque, NM - May 25, 1990 (5,435; 4,700 paid)

Advantage: Warrior
SACRAMENTO

SAVAGE:
WWF @ Sacramento, CA - Arco Arena - March 9, 1989 (5,000)


WARRIOR:
WWF @ Sacramento, CA - Arco Arena - July 19, 1990 (6,600)
WWF @ Sacramento, CA - Arco Arena - November 11, 1990 (7,450; 5,700 paid)

Advantage: Warrior

MSG is Advantage:Warrior though Savage headlined the building 6 times in 8 months huh?
 
Top