Star Trek Discovery Official Thread

MartyMcFly

What's up doc, can we rock?
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
59,888
Reputation
9,182
Daps
161,024
Reppin
P.G. County
They really wrote themselves into a corner making Burnham a mutineer. This episode (and pretty much any episode after the third one) could have been told even if she were just a regular officer on the Discovery, and arguably would have worked better. It also seems like nobody gives a fukk that she's a mutineer except for Admiral Cornwell (and Saru for the first couple episodes), and the only other time it comes up is when she's introduced to a new character and they go, "Oh, you're THAT Michael Burnham? :ohhh:" Tilly was looking to her for advice on how to be a Starfleet captain for Christ sakes. Burnham should be the last person to be asking that.

And now with Lorca offering her a spot on the bridge crew, that should be an interesting dynamic because nobody should be willing to fukk with her, but it'll probably get ignored for all the other storylines (finding the admiral, Klingon war, Lorca's self-destruction). I figured Lorca would either die or be relieved of duty by the end of the season (and he should because he's a piece of shyt), and it seems to be the direction they're going in, but if that happens Burnham goes right back to jail. There'd be no reason to keep her on the Discovery without Lorca vouching for her.

All that being said, I thought this was definitely one of the better episodes so far, which is good. I didn't like last week's episode at all.

Having her be the mutineer gives her the character arc tho. You can tell in the first two episodes she had a lot of baggage to begin with but now she’s working that shyt out while also “discovering” who she is again and what she’s about.
 

Raw Sauce

Superstar
Joined
Aug 16, 2015
Messages
8,840
Reputation
2,088
Daps
33,568
They really wrote themselves into a corner making Burnham a mutineer. This episode (and pretty much any episode after the third one) could have been told even if she were just a regular officer on the Discovery, and arguably would have worked better. It also seems like nobody gives a fukk that she's a mutineer except for Admiral Cornwell (and Saru for the first couple episodes), and the only other time it comes up is when she's introduced to a new character and they go, "Oh, you're THAT Michael Burnham? :ohhh:" Tilly was looking to her for advice on how to be a Starfleet captain for Christ sakes. Burnham should be the last person to be asking that.

And now with Lorca offering her a spot on the bridge crew, that should be an interesting dynamic because nobody should be willing to fukk with her, but it'll probably get ignored for all the other storylines (finding the admiral, Klingon war, Lorca's self-destruction). I figured Lorca would either die or be relieved of duty by the end of the season (and he should because he's a piece of shyt), and it seems to be the direction they're going in, but if that happens Burnham goes right back to jail. There'd be no reason to keep her on the Discovery without Lorca vouching for her.

All that being said, I thought this was definitely one of the better episodes so far, which is good. I didn't like last week's episode at all.
There's definitely going to be some friction between Burnham and Keyla once she's on the bridge.

Where are the andrions? Besides humans they are next most militaristic race.
The Andorians were mostly kept out of TNG era stuff because they looked corny. They made them look better in ENT but they probably used all their "upgrade a race's look" free rein with the Klingons.
 
Last edited:

Killigraphy

Banned
Joined
Mar 8, 2015
Messages
8,325
Reputation
-2,259
Daps
17,515
Reppin
NYC black coffee tough guys aka the Stoozy Boys
They really wrote themselves into a corner making Burnham a mutineer. This episode (and pretty much any episode after the third one) could have been told even if she were just a regular officer on the Discovery, and arguably would have worked better. It also seems like nobody gives a fukk that she's a mutineer except for Admiral Cornwell (and Saru for the first couple episodes), and the only other time it comes up is when she's introduced to a new character and they go, "Oh, you're THAT Michael Burnham? :ohhh:" Tilly was looking to her for advice on how to be a Starfleet captain for Christ sakes. Burnham should be the last person to be asking that.

And now with Lorca offering her a spot on the bridge crew, that should be an interesting dynamic because nobody should be willing to fukk with her, but it'll probably get ignored for all the other storylines (finding the admiral, Klingon war, Lorca's self-destruction). I figured Lorca would either die or be relieved of duty by the end of the season (and he should because he's a piece of shyt), and it seems to be the direction they're going in, but if that happens Burnham goes right back to jail. There'd be no reason to keep her on the Discovery without Lorca vouching for her.

All that being said, I thought this was definitely one of the better episodes so far, which is good. I didn't like last week's episode at all.

You could treat ep 5. as an entire easter egg. The whole three light- Ludivico style torture (Picard in Chain of command), Lorca rescuing beardy McPilot was also a throwback to the common ST trope, and of course Harry Mudd...the swindler and rouge himself. Played beautifully by Rain Wilson. I enjoyed it for the easter egg that it was, every episode can't be great, but learning more about Lorca was pretty nice.
 

Michael's Black Son

Blanket Jackson
Supporter
Joined
Sep 30, 2013
Messages
52,426
Reputation
15,169
Daps
230,400
Reppin
New York City & Neverland Ranch
When you realize the reason Sarek didn't talk to Spock for a decade....:ohhh:

Betrayed the "daughter" for the son...who never wanted to be like his dad...:francis:



"We'll have this conversation again...father.":gladbron:


Lorca going full Renegade :whoo:


The only problem with the show is the acronym; STD. :heh:

Welp, what’s a decade to a Vulcan? :ld:
 

Uchiha God

Veteran
Joined
Jan 11, 2013
Messages
14,342
Reputation
6,616
Daps
88,560
Reppin
NULL
Lorca is dark as fukk. dude clapped shorty cheeks then left her for dead just so he don't lose his ship :lolbron:
 

.r.

Veteran
Joined
Jul 2, 2015
Messages
14,122
Reputation
4,870
Daps
65,190
Still think the Ash Tyler thing is a ruse and Lorca is the "True" bad guy
Can't shake that

Technical dude a rape victum, wasn't that Klington chick fukk'n him in the mouth (or however Klington engage in foreplay) :smugdraper:
 

Raw Sauce

Superstar
Joined
Aug 16, 2015
Messages
8,840
Reputation
2,088
Daps
33,568
Technical dude a rape victum, wasn't that Klington chick fukk'n him in the mouth (or however Klington engage in foreplay) :smugdraper:
I'm pretty sure when he was beating her ass, *that* was Klingon foreplay.
 
Top