Spin: When did you finally realize that Jay Z's discography is borderline trash?

[nieman]

nas and jay both have a lot of mediocre albums with some good-great tracks on them, but some of you nikkas overrate nas albums on here too, the same argument can be made for both.

the only Nas album I've heard overrated on here is Life is Good. All of his other albums are properly rated.

 

[T.H.E. Goat]

Because it was better than that weed plate

They both were weedplates

But you're saying the best songs on Vol. 3 were better than the best songs on Nastradamus?

 

[semicko82]

They both were weedplates

But you're saying the best songs on Vol. 3 were better than the best songs on Nastradamus?

Yep So Ghetto is on another level

 

[bucks3115]

Hov the goat

fukk the haterz

 

[prophecypro]

the only Nas album I've heard overrated on here is Life is Good. All of his other albums are properly rated.

And thats an album that's praised outside of this place so its not like they wrong for that one

 

[NormanConnors]

nastradamus, streets disciple, HHID, untitled

Nastradamas being trash is one of the biggest myths in the histort of rap, track for the track it rounds out to a dope album.

at Untitled being on the list (in the land of the blind, the man with one eye is king) SD and HHID are debatable as well. It isn't as clear cut to note dud albums for Nas as it is for Jay

 

[mikishere]

Nastradamas being trash is one of the biggest myths in the histort of rap, track for the track it rounds out to a dope album.

at Untitled being on the list (in the land of the blind, the man with one eye is king) SD and HHID are debatable as well. It isn't as clear cut to note dud albums for Nas as it is for Jay

 

[QuintessentialMan]

Nastradamas being trash is one of the biggest myths in the histort of rap, track for the track it rounds out to a dope album.

at Untitled being on the list (in the land of the blind, the man with one eye is king) SD and HHID are debatable as well. It isn't as clear cut to note dud albums for Nas as it is for Jay

HHID is a dope album.

The dre track with Game

The song with Kanye West

The album actually had a running theme to it, he was trying to justify and explain why hhid. I loved it. He gave us some old school, shouted out all his fave past rappers on one track. It was a good album. I dont get why it gets disrespected.

 

[Devil Plisken…CMS]

man, I like Jay a lot.

Tried to play The Dynasty album a few days ago. No replay value whatsoever. 1900-Hustla is the best song on it.

This can't be life?
You Me Him Her?
Dynasty Intro?
Where Have You Been?

 

[JayBaldacci]

Jay has one album that you can argue as a true classic and thats RD. BP and other "classics" from that era are overrated.

Vol 3, BP2, KC, BP3 and MCHG are all weak albums.

 

[infamousred]

His discography is just like nas. They both only have 2 albums worth playing the whole way through.

 

[L. Deezy]

This can't be life?
You Me Him Her?
Dynasty Intro?
Where Have You Been?

well of coure Dynasty Intro.. thats on another level.

Album just doesnt flow well anymore.

 

[mobbinfms]

The coli tries sooooooo hard to find chinks in Jay's armor, it's hilarious.

That gif gives me PTSD.

 

[Devil Plisken…CMS]

stillmatic has songs like braveheart party, smokin, rule

the production is weak too

Smokin was hard!

 

[Devil Plisken…CMS]

well of coure Dynasty Intro.. thats on another level.

Album just doesnt flow well anymore.

I never saw it as a Jigga album myself so that helped