Spin: When did you finally realize that Jay Z's discography is borderline trash?

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,311
Reputation
15,400
Daps
93,595
Reppin
TPC
Blueprint 2 and MCHG are definitely weed plates but I think Blueprint 3 gets slagged too much. The :trash: timbo tracks really drag it down but its highs are super high. Thank You, DOA, Real as it Gets, Already Home, and So Ambitious>>>>>>>>>>

It's Vol. 1 status for me. Their are some genuine duds but its best tracks keep me coming back.
Vol 1 is way better than BP3
 

onelastdeath

Banned
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Messages
29,379
Reputation
11,075
Daps
134,962
nope1.gif
Good thing your opinion isn't fact :mjlol:

Y'all not gone get me into tearing down my two goats with your :flabbynsick: fukkery.

Have your opinion. We all do.
 

Billy Ocean

Divine Universal Black Man Representin'
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
42,778
Reputation
9,293
Daps
207,713
Reppin
TPC
Watch the throne was:trash:

nikkas in paris was overrated as fukk

OP kinda buggin though we know this is a response thread:francis:

How am I bugging though? I told everyone from jump that I'm a Jay fan and he's one of my favorite MCs ever. Which is fact. Why I gotta be bugging to point out that he has a good amount of mediocre or outright wack albums, bro?

And of course this is a response thread. That's why I put "spin" in the title.
 
Joined
Feb 28, 2015
Messages
794
Reputation
440
Daps
2,377
i can only listen to reasonable doubt, blueprint, black album and american gangster without skips. maybe vol 1
 

GPBear

The Tape Crusader
Joined
Mar 9, 2015
Messages
20,114
Reputation
4,760
Daps
67,422
Reppin
Bay-to-PDX
like i just coined that phrase an hour ago :dead:

must have touched a nerve tho :wrist:
No, I just think that as a white guy in a black culture it's bullshyt for you to try and ostracize others from the hip-hop community because of their differences by making them feel uncomfortable with epithets and slurs.

Not to mention you didn't add anything relevant to the discussion.
 

Jerz-2

GOATs Status
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
14,935
Reputation
4,668
Daps
54,701
Jay told you his debut is a classic, then...BOOM...Reasonable Doubt is a classic.

Jay told you that It Was Written was meh, then...BOOM...It Was Written was meh.

Jay told you that Nas makes 1 hot album every ten years, then...BOOM...Nas only makes 1 hot album every ten years.

Jay told nikkas "it's not biting, it's paying homage", then.....BOOM....suddenly, biting is the new wave.

I'mma big Jay fan but there's some truth to this thread. Like, BP3 really is NOT a classic to me, not by any stretch. And I always had a problem with Jay making "American Gangster" and saying it was "his own personal soundtrack to the movie" when (a) he TRIED to actually get the soundtrack and the movie execs crapped on the idea, and (2) he REALLY just made that album to quiet the backlash that he got for making "Kingdom Come", as most weren't ready to hear a "mature-sounding" Jay-Z at that point. I know he did it to save face but it just came off disingenuous.

But there ARE some hidden gems on some of the lackluster albums, just depends on personal affinity. Like, this will ALWAYS be my joint, I don't care what nikkas say (just listened to it earlier...but the original version, not this b.s. here, which is the only link I could find):



Also, one thing I never understood....why is Jay throwing up Dogg Pound Gangsta on the cover of BP2? Nobody else ever caught that? That's THEIR gang sign....
 
Last edited:
Top