@5n0man did you play on normal or hard?
Can’t speak on normal, but hard pretty much every main boss I had to adjust my lineup. I thought gameplay delivered personally. The non DLC superboss was a tough but great challenge imo.
Characters was a big drop from nocturne. Story was def a miss.
Gameplay was strong enough for me that it was worth it. Not great but personally found it in the solid to good range depending how much gameplay driven jrpgs suits you.
Outside of NieR Replicant and Kuro no Kiseki I’d honestly put it above any other Jrpg from that year. Those 2 being a remake and an unlocalized game.