Shedeur Sanders vs Caleb Williams as NFL prospects

How close are Shedeur and Caleb as prospects?


  • Total voters
    148

lib123

All Star
Joined
Jun 16, 2015
Messages
6,093
Reputation
329
Daps
12,257
Anyone on here go to Gonzaga? Seems like only the black Gonzaga alum are publicly celebrating Caleb Williams.

:mjpls:
 

Left.A1

Superstar
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
19,328
Reputation
714
Daps
51,576
:laff: :laff: :dead: :dead::dead:...you shytting on Caleb in here but said this last night bipolar ass nikka ...

:laff::laff::laff::laff::laff::laff:......
3 interceptions and under 200 yards with 5star talent all around him is worthy of being shytted on you incompetent nikka just like the buffs deserved the same ..:mjlol:




Thats what objective commentary not homer commentary looks like you corny dumb ass fukking groupie … now go look that word up simpleton ..because i know you’re too got damn dumb to know what it means :lolbron:
 
Last edited:

L&HH

Veteran
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
53,123
Reputation
5,780
Daps
161,371
Reppin
PG x MD
I’m a Caleb fan but is the following comparison appropriate:

Michael Penix is to CJ Stroud as Caleb Williams is to Bryce Young?
 

#1 pick

The Smart Negroes
Supporter
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
76,692
Reputation
11,197
Daps
197,458
Reppin
Lamb of God
Yall going overboard. Caleb is light yrs ahead of Shedeur. ND woulda did the same shyt to Shedeur
When blanently lying goes wrong. 2 does a lot better than this with way worse around him playing against better teams.

Sanders is simply a lot better. Caleb has the million dollar rare talent but none or that means anything if he's all bells and whistles.

Sanders is exactly good play by play. He's does it under duress. With a lot less talent around him. He's just a much better pocket passer. He's a 2nd coach on the field. He's just a much better QB for what many teams do at the next level. No question is 13 more gifted. That's a given compared to anyone for him. 2 is just a much better QB. Does it much better play by play over 13. It's been clear every time you watch each player play. Anyone saying otherwise simply doesn't pay attention.
 
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
42,291
Reputation
-5,967
Daps
47,689
Reppin
RENO, Nevada
When blanently lying goes wrong. 2 does a lot better than this with way worse around him playing against better teams.

Sanders is simply a lot better. Caleb has the million dollar rare talent but none or that means anything if he's all bells and whistles.

Sanders is exactly good play by play. He's does it under duress. With a lot less talent around him. He's just a much better pocket passer. He's a 2nd coach on the field. He's just a much better QB for what many teams do at the next level. No question is 13 more gifted. That's a given compared to anyone for him. 2 is just a much better QB. Does it much better play by play over 13. It's been clear every time you watch each player play. Anyone saying otherwise simply doesn't pay attention.
They both ass when playing real teams
 

#1 pick

The Smart Negroes
Supporter
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
76,692
Reputation
11,197
Daps
197,458
Reppin
Lamb of God
I’m a Caleb fan but is the following comparison appropriate:

Michael Penix is to CJ Stroud as Caleb Williams is to Bryce Young?
Penix isn't anywhere close to Stroud as a prospect. Penix is a pure pocket passer. Only 25 scrambles in 6 years playing college football. To put in perspective, Shedeur who isn't known for athleticism has 25 scrambles just this year in 7 games.

It's hard to find anyone to compare to Penix because just about everyone is more athletic than he is.

Penix is also 23 and will be 24 when the season starts next year. Williams is 21. A fair comparison for Williams will always be Pat Mahomes with far more polish as a prospect but the upside ain't nowhere close to Mahomes. He's short, doesn't really see over the OL well, he's more Russell Wilson like in the pocket but doesn't have anywhere near Wilson's elusiveness in the pocket. He doesn't anticipate as good as Wilson did coming out of Wisconsin.

For Williams, he's gonna need a coach and a GM that ain’t scared to build around him. He's not conventional.
 
Last edited:

#1 pick

The Smart Negroes
Supporter
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
76,692
Reputation
11,197
Daps
197,458
Reppin
Lamb of God
They both ass when playing real teams
Bro, 2 has played a number of real teams and really hasn't been ass once and his team is legit ass.

Look at this article


"If Colorado didn't have Shedeur, they wouldn't win a game, point blank, it's that simple," a Power 5 coach told ESPN. "He's getting killed, though. I feel bad. He's such a tough kid."
 
Top