You're an idiot
Shedeur Sanders vs Caleb Williams as NFL prospects
- Thread starter Apprentice
- Start date
CoCKy GeNiuS
Superstar
Once Shadeur develops his pocket awareness he will be the best in the game. Everything else is SUPER
This. Plus stop trying to do too much
Apprentice
RIP Doughboy Roc
Kurt has a point, there’s moments where Shaduer has enough time and holds that bytch too long.
I agree..a lot of those sacks are from Shedeur trying to be a hero and holding the ball instead of throwing it away or looking to run ..You saw today his awareness and internal clock was different than it’s been most of the year … getting rid of the ball quickly …running quickly .. and it resulted in only 3 sacks …the one time he tried to play hero ball he tossed the int
Caleb played well, but this is a defense that gave up 42 points to TCU back when the defense was actually healthy and Hunter/Sanders were in on every snap. 35 to Colorado State, including 370 yards passing and 3 TDs to their QB. 42 to Oregon by the first drive of the second half.
And now they had to try and defend against a stacked offense with their two biggest stars out.
It doesn't really say that much.
Dr. Narcisse
Veteran
I really hope breh is humble enough to return for another season and dont think his "stats" mean he's ready for the pros. These spread offenses are built to put up yards in college.
His Total QBR is 36th in the country (not talking passer rating but overall game score)
He scrambles into too many sacks, takes his first read/check down way too much, doesnt always anticipate, etc etc.
Speaking of Jameis. I think he left college too soon (but probably had too). He took some bad habits to the pros with him and it was hard to shake.
He needs to come back for his SR year and really round out his game and then can elevate. Look at Joe Burrow and Herbert as guys who benefited from another year. Now tbf Herbert got a much better arm and both seem way more athletic than Shedeur
Honestly rather see him not care about his completion % and just throw more big boy NFL throws.
His Total QBR is 36th in the country (not talking passer rating but overall game score)
He scrambles into too many sacks, takes his first read/check down way too much, doesnt always anticipate, etc etc.
Speaking of Jameis. I think he left college too soon (but probably had too). He took some bad habits to the pros with him and it was hard to shake.
He needs to come back for his SR year and really round out his game and then can elevate. Look at Joe Burrow and Herbert as guys who benefited from another year. Now tbf Herbert got a much better arm and both seem way more athletic than Shedeur
Honestly rather see him not care about his completion % and just throw more big boy NFL throws.
DropTopDoc
20/20 Vision With my Buffs On
Far from a Deion apologist here, but
He also scrambled to first downs and tds, given his line play that’s something that can be corrected in the pros, but long as he has the get up out of here alarm he’s going to be ok
Winston left with nothing left but to tank his nfl prospects, he won the hiesman and a nc and a playoff appearance, getting in the league is just as much as getting there when your stock is hot, as it is improving it’s a lot of qbs that may have never got drafted had they come back and had a shyt year or more film to critique, and even more that got hurt by that extra year, at that point it’s up to the new coaches to help make you better, learn what you can do, and accentuate tf out of it
They make money in college now so he has no reason to leave yet, he'll be back, but I don't believe in this notion that staying in college will make you a better QB. If the professional coaches that draft you can't prepare you for the professional game, no one can.
There's a lot of factors in the jump from college to pro that I think get ignored in this conversation, the size of the professional football (accurate college QBs aren't always accurate in the pros because of this), the scheme of the team that drafts you, your teammates, job security of your coaches, etc.
PFF grades
Sanders v. Williams
premium.pff.com
premium.pff.com
Sanders had a superior grade to Williams. @Trojan 24, you are an idiot
Sanders v. Williams
Premium Stats
Our exclusive database, featuring the most in-depth collection of NFL and NCAA player performance data.
premium.pff.com
Premium Stats
Our exclusive database, featuring the most in-depth collection of NFL and NCAA player performance data.
premium.pff.com
Sanders had a superior grade to Williams. @Trojan 24, you are an idiot
Trojan 24
Veteran
PFF grades
Sanders v. Williams
Premium Stats
Our exclusive database, featuring the most in-depth collection of NFL and NCAA player performance data.
Premium Stats
Our exclusive database, featuring the most in-depth collection of NFL and NCAA player performance data.
Sanders had a superior grade to Williams. @Trojan 24, you are an idiot
Let me know what the GMs decide at the end of the year
Sheduer out here stat padding
No he wasn't. Your team was running the same defense from beginning to end. Same blitzes. Same stunts. Same everything. Uncreative ass defense.Let me know what the GMs decide at the end of the year
Sheduer out here stat padding
Watch the damn snaps. What Shedeur is doing is harder. That doesn't change the fact that Caleb has tremendous and rare talent but what he's doing isn't all that hard. What Sanders is doing translates to the NFL
feelosofer
#ninergang
Shadeur could benefit from another year in college.