He was top 10 or better in almost every meaningful statistic in passing, Jimmy shouldn't be punished because he is surrounded by a very good team. He did what he had to do and to be honest, Kyle's poor 2nd half gameplanning was as more to blame than Jimmy's play. Why doesn't Mahomes get that same energy, he didn't play well in the superbowl either. That's my thing Jimmy gets punished for shyt that other QBs don't get punished for.
I'm going on eye test... Mahomes can be handed the ball and make miracles.. And does it CONSISTENTLY.. I haven't seen Jimmy make any. I do not think, if Jimmy was on these other teams, that he'd produce and be that #1 reason you win the game. Those other guys are.
And this is his first full season with no injury. The book isn't closed. Lord knows I hope he gets there. But imagine this team with those other qb's on the list. Do we get better or worse?
TIER 2
Brady - Better
Lamar - Ehhhh but with our run game, I'd say better... Passing we all know
Ben - Better
Stafford - Ehhhh.. I know his arm is better, but we ain't seen him in the clutch either
Matt Ryan - Better
Wentz - Better if healthy
Dak - Better
Rivers - Better
I'm saying with our running game, you can plug almost anyone in and get the same RUNNING results... I don't think Jimmy is a better passer than these guys beyond Lamar
he played for the Vikings before he retired
