to the bolded: you don't know that it's highly unlikely that that hypothetical squad would be a Finals contender. It involves too much stuff that may or may not be feasible given their situation. Sometimes you can make the right picks and it still doesn't mean anything. Hell, that team had Love, Big Al, and a war chest and nobody wanted the job as a coach OR GM. Hell, they have a team that if healthy could fukk around and make the playoffs and have Love, Rubio, Pek, etc. and watch nobody STILL want the GM job. Some situations in the NBA are much steeper climbs than others. I don't wanna keep making this about my team because inherently we could never compete for a championship, but that's another story.
If you draft and trade well for a decade, you should be good. In the NFL I might not have to do that well over a long period of time to contend. In baseball, I don't have to do that to contend. Hell, depending on where you are, you don't have to do that in the NBA to contend. According to you, the Knicks got to where they are now and they fukked up. Unless the organization is completely out of order, I can conceivably take your organization and turn it around faster with more margin for error than I could in the NBA with less margin for error.