It’s still early but magic 2 is easily at the bottom for me.
Rank the Nas and Hit Boy Albums
- Thread starter I'm Blackman
- Start date
It’s still early but magic 2 is easily at the bottom for me.
Abstract83
Superstar
I got it ranked at the top. Then it's magic, KD 3, then KD 2. Magic 2, KD. But I gotta give it more time.
Canada Goose
Pooping on your head :umad:
Magic
KD1
Magic 3
Didn't care for the other albums in the series.
KD1
Magic 3
Didn't care for the other albums in the series.
Figaro
Superstar
KD2/Magic 4.5/5
KD3/Magic 3 4.25/5
KD1 4/5
Magic 2 3/5
I've actually lowered the Magic 2 score because besides 1 or 2 songs I hardly play it...
KD3/Magic 3 4.25/5
KD1 4/5
Magic 2 3/5
I've actually lowered the Magic 2 score because besides 1 or 2 songs I hardly play it...
It’s somewhere in the top 3. I believe the universal top 3 after everything settles down will be KD3, Magic, & Magic 3
KD2 gets an honorable mention for being such a well constructed cinematic album. I definitely understand if that’s people’s #1 choice, that album felt big, from the production to the features. To be honest I woulda expected that album to pull in the Grammy instead of KD1
But KD3, Magic, Magic 3 were for the core fan base
Slim Charles
All Star
Was bored so decided to rate each track on each album to find an average rating for each album
Generally matched up to my rankings but KD2 pretty close to Magic 3. KD2 for me has more 5/5 tracks but Magic 3 little more consistent. Caveat to the below is I don’t think this the right way to rate an album as one bad track can fukk up an average but thought interesting to see how it turned out this way.
Magic - 4.7
KD3- 4.4
Magic 3- 4.3
KD2- 4.3
KD- 4
Magic 3- 3.7
Generally matched up to my rankings but KD2 pretty close to Magic 3. KD2 for me has more 5/5 tracks but Magic 3 little more consistent. Caveat to the below is I don’t think this the right way to rate an album as one bad track can fukk up an average but thought interesting to see how it turned out this way.
Magic - 4.7
KD3- 4.4
Magic 3- 4.3
KD2- 4.3
KD- 4
Magic 3- 3.7
JoelB
All Praise To TMH
1. Illmatic
2. Lost Tapes
3. It Was Written
4. Stillmatic
5. Kings Disease 3
6. Magic 3
7. Life Is Good
8. Kings Disease 2
9. Distant Relatives
10. Magic 1
11. Untitled
12. I am...
13. God's Son
14. Kings Disease 1
15. Nastradamus
16. Hip-Hop Is Dead
17. Magic 2
18. Streets Disciple
19. Lost Tapes 2
20. Nasir
4/6 of the Nas/HB albums cracked the top 10 got damn
2. Lost Tapes
3. It Was Written
4. Stillmatic
5. Kings Disease 3
6. Magic 3
7. Life Is Good
8. Kings Disease 2
9. Distant Relatives
10. Magic 1
11. Untitled
12. I am...
13. God's Son
14. Kings Disease 1
15. Nastradamus
16. Hip-Hop Is Dead
17. Magic 2
18. Streets Disciple
19. Lost Tapes 2
20. Nasir
4/6 of the Nas/HB albums cracked the top 10 got damn
BK The Great
Veteran
KD3 - 5/5
KD2 - 4/5
KD1 - 4/5
Magic 1 - 5/5
Magic 2 - 3/5
Magic 3 - 4/5
KD2 - 4/5
KD1 - 4/5
Magic 1 - 5/5
Magic 2 - 3/5
Magic 3 - 4/5
HNIC973
R.I.P Bandana P
Magic
KD3
Magic 3
KD2
KD1
Magic 2
KD3
Magic 3
KD2
KD1
Magic 2
Magic 3
KD2
KD3
Magic 2
Magic 1
KD1
And really these ranking s come down to personal preference as each of these six albums are fukking superb.
KD2 for all this time has been my favorite, but Nas REALLY went into his storytelling bag for Magic 3 while also throwing in some of what I loved about pretty much all of the previous albums.
I’ll be listening to every single one of these albums for years to come.
Salutes to the GOAT
KD2
KD3
Magic 2
Magic 1
KD1
And really these ranking s come down to personal preference as each of these six albums are fukking superb.
KD2 for all this time has been my favorite, but Nas REALLY went into his storytelling bag for Magic 3 while also throwing in some of what I loved about pretty much all of the previous albums.
I’ll be listening to every single one of these albums for years to come.
Salutes to the GOAT