They don't really compare to each other. One is turn based strategy and the other is real time action.
Persona 5 Royal | PS4 | PC/PS5/SW/XSX/S,XBO 10/21/22
- Thread starter Fatboi1
- Start date
Dallas' 4 Eva
Superstar
I know I said I wasn't gonna replay this... but I think I'm gonna replay this. 
bigdaddy88
The King Of Power
I will pay the full 60 for scramble..proper sequel
Last edited:
tinnyskillz
Superstar
*There's NO SPOILERS in this post*
I beat Persona 4 early 2018, and it's probably in my top 5 games i've ever played. And i played it 10 years/2 gens late. That's how great that game is. I started Persona 5 Royal (never played the vanilla version) on Merciless difficulty in late June. Got like 45 minutes in, then put it down. I was lowkey not feeling it (i wasn't struggling btw, P4 made me a Persona veteran).
I didn't like the UI at first (it's the GOAT to me now, idk it just clicked with me after a while). I thought there was too much going on with the games art direction etc. I didn't REALLY give it a chance, and started playing it until late August, maybe early September. I loved Kamashida's Palace (probably in my top 3 favorite palace list in this game). I think i binged played ten straight hours one day on that one palace/section of the game no cap. The second palace was just ok to me. Still fun nonetheless.
The third palace was great. The story, team, and characters overall started to get a little more interesting. I'd say around this time. Things began to pickup, and i became more invested into the game. Around the fourth palace is a very high point of the game to me. I REALLY was into the story, characters, and just the game in general then. Super fun time in, and around the fourth palace (top 3 palace).
I hated the fifth palace. I was so relieved when it was over. It made me so mad how long, and drawn out that palace was. I got tired of looking at it. Looking back it doesn't seem so bad. But in real-time i absolutely wanted to dropkick the developers who coded that palace one by one lol. I think it's one of those palaces that's fun to watch someone play, and complain about. Not play yourself.
I'd argue that in, and around Palace six is the peak of the game. The story is at it's best/climax at this point. The palace itself is amazing from the design, to the puzzles, and challenges thrown at you (top 3 palace). I was on the boss fight on Halloween night (irl). Which is around the same time in the game. Now usually i'd throw on a few horror movies in tradition. This year, i had myself some candy, in my bed, playing possibly the game of the generation. Felt like a young bull again
After palace six the game took a more serious turn/tone. I liked the remaining palaces. It's just i felt there were a few times the game could have been wrapped up, or at least shortened (cut some material out the game to be more time efficient) but it kind of overstayed it's welcome. Don't get it twisted i still loved the game. Palace seven (yacht) was awesome. Palace eight was ok (not the worst palace), and the Mementos was a great addition to the series. I got the true ending my first try, no cheating, looking up guides (i did reddit two op bosses, but it didn't help at all), or anything.
As i was with P4. I was sad when i beat the game Wednesday night. 125 hours Merciless Completed. All long exciting journeys must come to an end at some point. P4 may edge out P5 but not by much. P5 Is a more polished, and refined P4. P5R is either my GOTG, or it's a close 2nd. I rate it a 9.5. out of 10.
And to think i wasn't really feeling it at first. ClassicCan't wait for P6. I'm actually kind of speed running a NG+. I missed maxing out a certain confidant that adds an extra semester, and palace to the game. I need that for the platinum. I got 90% of the trophies so why not.
Oh, and btw the soundtrack will forever be in my rotation. I LOVE THIS SONG in the timestamped video. BEAUTIFUL, SOULFUL, GROOVY DISCO VIBES:
I wish i could go back to when i first heard this song, and played that palace. I was like
If you haven't played this game yet. Please do. You can get lost in it's world there's so much to do in this game. With everything that's going on in the world right now irl. It's the perfect game to play to "escape". So much fun being a Phantom thief.
I beat Persona 4 early 2018, and it's probably in my top 5 games i've ever played. And i played it 10 years/2 gens late. That's how great that game is. I started Persona 5 Royal (never played the vanilla version) on Merciless difficulty in late June. Got like 45 minutes in, then put it down. I was lowkey not feeling it (i wasn't struggling btw, P4 made me a Persona veteran).
I didn't like the UI at first (it's the GOAT to me now, idk it just clicked with me after a while). I thought there was too much going on with the games art direction etc. I didn't REALLY give it a chance, and started playing it until late August, maybe early September. I loved Kamashida's Palace (probably in my top 3 favorite palace list in this game). I think i binged played ten straight hours one day on that one palace/section of the game no cap. The second palace was just ok to me. Still fun nonetheless.
The third palace was great. The story, team, and characters overall started to get a little more interesting. I'd say around this time. Things began to pickup, and i became more invested into the game. Around the fourth palace is a very high point of the game to me. I REALLY was into the story, characters, and just the game in general then. Super fun time in, and around the fourth palace (top 3 palace).
I hated the fifth palace. I was so relieved when it was over. It made me so mad how long, and drawn out that palace was. I got tired of looking at it. Looking back it doesn't seem so bad. But in real-time i absolutely wanted to dropkick the developers who coded that palace one by one lol. I think it's one of those palaces that's fun to watch someone play, and complain about. Not play yourself.
I'd argue that in, and around Palace six is the peak of the game. The story is at it's best/climax at this point. The palace itself is amazing from the design, to the puzzles, and challenges thrown at you (top 3 palace). I was on the boss fight on Halloween night (irl). Which is around the same time in the game. Now usually i'd throw on a few horror movies in tradition. This year, i had myself some candy, in my bed, playing possibly the game of the generation. Felt like a young bull again
After palace six the game took a more serious turn/tone. I liked the remaining palaces. It's just i felt there were a few times the game could have been wrapped up, or at least shortened (cut some material out the game to be more time efficient) but it kind of overstayed it's welcome. Don't get it twisted i still loved the game. Palace seven (yacht) was awesome. Palace eight was ok (not the worst palace), and the Mementos was a great addition to the series. I got the true ending my first try, no cheating, looking up guides (i did reddit two op bosses, but it didn't help at all), or anything.
As i was with P4. I was sad when i beat the game Wednesday night. 125 hours Merciless Completed. All long exciting journeys must come to an end at some point. P4 may edge out P5 but not by much. P5 Is a more polished, and refined P4. P5R is either my GOTG, or it's a close 2nd. I rate it a 9.5. out of 10.
And to think i wasn't really feeling it at first. Classic
Can't wait for P6. I'm actually kind of speed running a NG+. I missed maxing out a certain confidant that adds an extra semester, and palace to the game. I need that for the platinum. I got 90% of the trophies so why not.Oh, and btw the soundtrack will forever be in my rotation. I LOVE THIS SONG in the timestamped video. BEAUTIFUL, SOULFUL, GROOVY DISCO VIBES:
I wish i could go back to when i first heard this song, and played that palace. I was like
If you haven't played this game yet. Please do. You can get lost in it's world there's so much to do in this game. With everything that's going on in the world right now irl. It's the perfect game to play to "escape". So much fun being a Phantom thief.
Last edited:
tinnyskillz
Superstar
MVP(Futaba, Ryuji, Makoto, and Ann as well) Morgana is Lisa Kudrow's little sister
(Futaba, Ryuji, Makoto, and Ann as well) Morgana is Lisa Kudrow's little sister
Last edited:
tinnyskillz
Superstar
Currently watching Persona 5 The Animation with Motion Interpolation. It's so smooth
MVP
She's on the path to becoming Troy Baker / Laura Bailey famous and leaving all these anime style games behind. If it keeps up she's gonna be out of their budget like Troy is. I first noticed her in Tales of Grace's as Sophie. She's pretty good but she's kinda like Troy where when they have her do a character it's mostly a default voice.
Erika Harlacher who plays Ann in Persona 5 might have next. She did a great job recently in Cold Steel III and IV as Juna.
Khalil's_Black_Excellence
The King of Fighters
Currently watching Persona 5 The Animation with Motion Interpolation. It's so smooth
Where are you watching this at?
Dallas' 4 Eva
Superstar
You can watch it on the funimation app dubbed/subbed or watch it subbed on Hulu.
Animal House
Superstar
It’s one of the best Tales games imo
Khalil's_Black_Excellence
The King of Fighters
Word. I have Funimation too and didn't know. Must've been added not too long ago, as I searched for a few months ago.
I see they got Persona 4 as well. Both getting added to my favorites now.
Khalil's_Black_Excellence
The King of Fighters
Currently watching Persona 5 The Animation with Motion Interpolation. It's so smooth
Yeah, this shyt is really clean. Emulates the game pretty perfectly. Got almost all the original VAs in as well.
Superkick Party
Atlus / Ryū ga Gotoku
Buy the battle dlc whenever it goes on sale and fight Makoto and YuI know I said I wasn't gonna replay this... but I think I'm gonna replay this.
Brief Keef
Superstar
just started this...seems wack