i paid 60 for p5
but gameply/story-wise, how different is it from the original?
Currently on a 2nd playthrough in Royal. Think its different enough to get a fresh experience, worth buying for less than full price. You have more activities to do with a new town opening up. Can play darts to increase baton pass bonuses (became my favorite minigame), visit a jazz club with a teammate, meditate at a temple etc
There's a "showtime" mechanic where two party members will do a cinematic super. Most of them are great.
Some enemies will glow blue/purple. If you kill them they'll explode and do collateral damage to other enemies, also give you a special item. But if you hit them and they don't die then they'll attack right back.
Morgana doesn't restrict you from exploring the city as much. So you have more time to do what you want.
Palaces have a new side objective - collecting three hidden items (will seeds) that will give you a special accessory, and also restore some health/SP. Joker also has a grappling hook that he can use to access certain ledges. Palaces have been reworked around that.
You can press the home button and to get a fast travel prompt on what to do next, like visit a specific confident or do an activity. The best QOL change to me.
There's two more confidants. One of them allows you to do a 3rd semester which extends the game by a lot (I didn't realize this until AFTER the first playthrough, though....gotta max him before a certain date). Apparently in this semester you can do a 3rd transformation of your confidants personas.
There's a traveling merchant in Mementos who you can unlock rewards from by collecting items in your path. Makes Mementos more fun.
There's The Thieves Den which is like a trophy room where you can organize all of your in game achievements and spend points to unlock stuff. Gives you more incentive to do certain activities, like working out in your room and in the gym until you can do bruce lee moves on that training dummy. Then you get in game points for that.
There are enough differences to make P5 obsolete. Worth getting on sale