Tom Brady
1st Super Bowl: Only reached it because of the nonsense Tuck Rule. And only won by a late field goal over the Rams.
2nd Super Bowl: Carolina Panthers kicker John Kasay kicked the ball out of bounds (something that almost never ever happens) in the final minute, giving the Patriots the ball at the 40. They won by a late field goal.
3rd Super Bowl: Eked out another 3 point win against a less-than-100% Terrell Owens who was beasting. Donovan McNabb had the testicular fortitude of a 12 year old girl and blew it for the Eagles.
4th Super Bowl: A 4-point win over the Seahawks due to the single worst call in recorded human history.
Two Super Bowl losses to Eli Manning; a player so universally despised by fans around the country that he might be the 1st quarterback with 2 Super Bowl rings to not make the Hall of Fame.
Tom Brady as the best quarterback ever?