Thoughts/Review/Spoliers/
I saw it late last night, and I basically agree with the NY Times review, which isn't as positive as I thought, before watching. There was a lot I really liked, the masterful performances from the leads (old pro's, very much in line with their characters) and hilarious cameos, (Al Pacino, and the producer, when he revved his hands like a motorcycle) the fact that Tartantino seemed to finally be making movies about real people, or real characters, and got some of the humanity back, that to me, hasn't really been there since Death Proof. The movie flows so easily and natural as the interactions between the old friends, at it's center. The direction is brilliant, and I love when Tarantino channels the horror genre, like the subtle nods of malice about the clan of hippies descending upon the Hollywood Hills, and the larger world, inch by inch.
The scenes where the now infamous Cielo Drive is slowly shown, as the camera pans back, was perfect, and the way he showed how vulnerable the stars were, just living freely, so much, that, Charles Manson just wanders into the front yard. Margot Robie is captivating, kind, completely channeling the stars of the 1960's, and the era, before instagram and snapchat, a highly privileged and talented young woman, who carried herself with and 'everyday" grace and elegance. The day to day live and inner thoughts of the characters was compelling, funny, and entirely Tarantino, but perhaps a more refined, mature, relaxed Tarantino, who effortlessly shifts between a funny, and heartfelt scene with Decaprio's character revealing his insecurity and heartbreak to a fellow actor, too young to be competition, too old to be cynical.
The scene where Timothy Olyphant asks Dalton if he was almost chosen for The Great Escape, was one of the movie's funniest moments, as I am familiar with many of the old movies referenced and idealized by Tarantino. Tarantino is at home to capture his obsessions and our obsessions with the 1960's, and a bygone era, with the same charm and grace as his cast. I do see the somewhat odd, or unexpected conservatism that he seems to embrace more and, more directly, than I have ever seen from his films, even the later ones. There is a very much a "real man" mystique, that isn't quite played for laughs, and a level of violence directed towards the "dirty hippies" and also, yes, again, women.
Like the NY Times review says, it is basically a western, in the vein of Rio Bravo and El Dorado, the good guys ambling around town, til the bad guys arrive in the last act. The last act, to me, is where the movie lost me, or essentially dropped down into a more predictable, lesser movie. I may have been naive in thinking Tarantino would follow through on the actual killings, with reverence and horror, and not pull the punch everyone expected him to, which is to turn it into a comedic violent spectacle, a righting of wrongs, and a "what could have been"? The themes of which are somewhat troubling, esp. the brutal beating of one female Manson follower, to some of the audiences delight. I felt it coming, as I realized that it was doubtful Tarantino would portray the murders with a Kurt Russell narration. I wanted to see that movie, where Cliff and Rick are basically helpless bystanders to the brutal killings, and left without innocence, as the rest of Hollywood, and California was, after the summer of 1969.
Those scenes, through staged well, and not without a certain charm, are entirely the new Tarantino, brutal and comic violence, goofy characterizations of the Manson followers, and the good guys saving the day. It's a fairy tale, and it's all there in the title.