GOAT- Empire Strikes Back, a New Hope
Great- Return of the Jedi
Aight- Revenge of the Sith*
Mediocre- Rogue One, Force Awakens**
Meh- Solo
Bad- Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones
TRASH- The Last Jedi, Rise of Skywalker
* Revenge of the Sith is BY FAR the most overrated movie in the franchise by miles. I'm still putting it ahead of the Disney movies though since the prequel trilogy at least had a vision and a plan behind it. Palpatine and Obi-wan were the best parts of the movie, IMO. Order 66 was also handled pretty well.
** TLJ and Ros have retroactively ruined the Force Awakens for me. It's harder to enjoy episode VII knowing that it leads to those two dumpster fire sequels they tried to make.
We never got a a proper Luke/Han/Leia reunion, they jobbed out Finn, made Rey way too powerful, and they wasted the guys from the Raid. Imagine these dudes coming at you with lightsabers