Just saw it and I liked it a lot. DK's acting was fire, you really believed him as a ranch guy who just wanted to be on his ranch and didn't deal with other people outside the family like that. Cinematography was beautiful. Plot repeatedly subverted expectations - the alien kids fake-out, the praying mantis fake-out, the UFO being alive, Jupiter already knowing way more than they did, OJ's plan working to perfection only having to re-run everything on the fly because old nature photographer dude wanted his pure moment, and the UFO getting got by the most inane foe in the end.
It was tight how Peele managed to weave in at least three major themes rather than just following some cookie-cutter narrative:
* Talent being exploited and spit out by the Hollywood industry. The Haywoods, Jupiter, the horses, the chimp, they were all exploited by that Hollywood machine that didn't give a shyt about their own well-being. Even the Fry's guy had been tossed to the side once his girl got a taste of that Hollywood fame.
* Clout-chasing overrides people's rational faculties. Over and over, everyone who got fukked up (outside of the innocent tourists) did so because they were trying to get that perfect instagram shot and be famous.
* Wild animals need to be treated like they're wild. You can't just walk all over them, you can't assume anything about them, you can't pretend you've tamed them. From the chimp to the horses to the UFO, ignoring the lesson gets you fukked up.
And the genre-bending was awesome - it was a hardscrabble "gotta save the ranch" family movie but also a horror movie but also a Western.
My only negative is that it didn't feel entirely smooth - there were disjointed elements that it seemed like Peele could have incorporated into the narrative better. Jupiter already having this long-ass relationship with the beast was foreshadowed but too heavy-handed, I wish there was a smoother way they could have shown that he knew something was going on (though I think Jupiter scenes probably look a lot different on rewatch). Cinematographer man was a bit out-of-place and overacted, I wish they had worked him in earlier. And the world knowing about the disappearance of 40 people but not having some massive LEO presence out there was too big a plot hole - all those people dying either should have been a bigger deal or just have been toned down to make it more seemless.
That lack of smoothness is the difference between this being a "neat" movie to me and a "great" movie.