this might be the stan in me talking but jon is the first death I felt was a reach. they built up his character to be be completely loyal to the nightswatch. they even put extra emphasis on that by having him turn down stannis this season. so jon going for the wildlings and disregarding the feelings of the nightswatch people completely went against the character they made him out to be. he had to know it would end in a mutiny. there was just too much history and bloodshed with the wildlings for him to believe it would be all good. and then the way they killed him with that weak ass uncle shyt. no way he falls for that simple shyt. this one just feels like jon died because shock deaths have become the norm now. I know it's in the books but still....I gotta believe even for the book readers it had to be like "really"?
......or maybe the build up to his death was done much better in the books