thanks for the responses, two comments though
1)My relatives don't have raised gardens, but ground level gardens separate from lawn and along fence of neighboring property. Even with soil preparation there are occasional weeds . In all instances,neighbors don't tend their yards at all.
Gonna try just pulling the weeds up, but my first inclination was to lift weeds and then claw the soil.
2) With all the rain that fell throughout parts of the country, I would think that even people who don't normally claw/scratch/turn soil between plaints would do so because of all that water. Get oxygen into the soil.
Yeah so you'll never get rid of weeds. If that is your concern, abandon it. especially in the case of your neighbors not preventing weeds from going to seed. The ways to not have weeds are to grow indoors, hydro, or herbicides.
Water penetration, soil penetration doesnt necessarily equate to aeration. What do the forests have for rain to get into? Grassland prairies? Worms and plant density. Once a dandelion dies the long taproot shrivels up and then makes a cavern for water penetration and aeration. You can plant carrots and radishes to do the same thing. In the winter plant wheat/rye to do the same thing. Growing your soil is not just and up but and in and down thing.
Disturbing the relationship of the microbial life thru usage of the claw is what I'm against. There are complex anaerobic and aerobic populations and conditions going on that I'm going to leave as they are. I understand your usage of it, this is what I understand about my practices, and my ag philosophy.