"Carried their teams" ?
Nobody has CARRIED their team more than AD has. He's literally all Minnesota has. If you take Tom Brady away from New England you still have one of the best running games in the NFL. You still have a defense that has forced the second most turnovers in the NFL.
Manning? He's QB of a team in the worst division in the NFL. One of the worst divisions in NFL history. Denver's defense is second in the league in sacks. Not to mention this same team won a playoff game last year without him.
Then you have a guy putting up one of the top RB seasons ever, on a team with no QB, no WR's, average defense...who single handedly is truly CARRYING his team to the playoffs.
THERE IS NO DEBATE.