If you can write a story and know about good guys and bad guys, then you can write a script for this carny bullshyt. I doubt she's booking the actual matches, which is what i think these dudes are bytching about. It 100% helps to have somebody NOT caught up the wrestling bubbling to come in every once in a while and see the holes that others won't see.
This.... cause I've definitely seen "fans", that "know about wrestling" and think they would do a sooooo much better job, come up with some awful ass ideas that would play out just as terribly if not worse on tv.
Personally, I think it'd be much better with a smaller circle for each show consisting of people in the business who actually do know this shyt and have experience in what works.
But hiring "fans" who'd probably make everything to favor their personal favorites and maybe have 3 good ideas would likely fare just as poorly as hiring TV writers who don't watch it.
These writers ain't booking the matches anyway, that's what the producers and Vince do.