Yes man and I’ll explain why lol.
Nas feels so out of pocket and out of his element here. Like extremely. Echo? That’s a Nas song. That’s him in his element and sounding like he cares and having the common decency to find a pocket on the beat. He put out 7 songs and there are maybe two that I really still mess with and would put on a Nas playlist. And even then they’d be low on the playlist.
He’s at his best observing the world around him and juxtaposing that world with his inner thoughts or sins or telling stories. This album is mostly him being hedonistic and that’s never worked for him. Kanye said he wanted to make the Nas he likes and apparently he likes I Am era Nas because for me, that’s what this feels like. Hollow and vapid and surface level. Even Cops Shot The Kid, which I like, is a lesser version of songs he’s made in the past with more insightful observations. Meanwhile on Echo, he says more in that 2-3 min that he did on this whole album.
After my initial hype wore off I just couldn’t get with this anymore and it’s real telling that as soon as it dropped he was already talking about the next album with swizz and rza and said this is something Kanye wanted to do. To me, that implies this was a Kanye album not a Nas album.
Just my thoughts tho. I couldn’t put it all into words until I heard Echo. But I’m glad you or anyone else are still feeling this album. I wish I was in the same boat. Just expected more from Nasty as I always do
i actually think the album came out a classic
i believe everyone thought it would be 10 "still dreamings"
it just wasnt the album everyone wanted or expected
what makes a nas album for me is three fold;
lyrics are rebel to america
concepts are what up kid
beats are turn the bass up
if he hits these nodes then i am happy as a listener and for nas he has been very consistent since his first album
this is just another chapter in his legacy and i find this album to be what pusha or kanye said it was "all of nas best moments"
not songs; moments. i find every song to be a nod to nas best moments post it was written.
radio / streets disciple
cops / godson
white / i am
bonjour / hiphop is dead
everything / life is good
simple / stillmatic
adam / lost tapes
end of the day its all opinions and i respect someone explaining they position
NASIR as a release was an experiment; its creation process was the opposite of nas usual creation cycle
it was created under a tight time constraint as opposed to the usual
album wouldve sounded better if the mixing/mastering was better. some of the songs sound "undone" or have to be nudged/cut etc.
at the end of the day i dont care about static or demos or any of that shyt; i actually love it if the music is good