Fair point. I think the top 4 is prob air tight for most people since it's prob gonna be some mixture of Illmatic, IWW, Stillmatic, and Lost Tapes. I feel like most people settled on Life Is Good being at least a top 6-7 album at least right? For me it's number 5.
SD is low on my list but it's one of those albums that super flawed yet underrated and fascinating to me. I always liked albums like that where you're like fukk...just a couple obvious changes could have made this a straight up 4/5. Hearing Salaam and Chucky Thompson talk about it interviews, the album was entirely different for much of the time they worked on it. Talk Of New York, Serious, and some other bangers were on there before being removed.
@Ziggiy it fluctuates so right now I'm just weighing the rapping on Nastradamus over Untitled. Also I don't fukk with most of the production on Untitled. Beats are underwhelming as fukk on there IMO and I'll always dislike the tone (I feel like it should have been more bombastic and aggressive like the mixtape). Nothing on the album is worse than the lowest lows on Nastradamus (Big Girl, Brave New World etc) but the highs of Nastradamus are just better to me. The Premo track, Life We Chose, Project Windows, etc.