My Hero Academia would be better without Deku as the main protagonist

Would MHA be better without Deku as the main character?

  • Yes

    Votes: 28 40.6%
  • No

    Votes: 41 59.4%

  • Total voters
    69

brickflair

All Star
Joined
Jan 24, 2016
Messages
1,315
Reputation
242
Daps
4,906
Reppin
Queens, NY
He ain't *anything* enough is the problem. Dude is the worst Mary Sue in the game right now. The bytch from Twilight got more direction and purpose than Deku does.

Yal giving him props for shyt he hasn't done or thing he's done the opposite in comparison to people in his own series

He wants to save lives. Ok. How come he's not making special moves that are deliberately for rescue operations like some of the others in his own class :ohhh:

He's about the culture, but when All Might shows Deku that he has demons and regrets time and time again, does he ask? :mjlol: fukk all that. We good with the top 10 All Might moments.

Deku = Lil Bow Wow in Like Mike
Deku has his own regrets like when him and Mirio aint save Eri initially or when he couldnt save Bakugo but this arc is shaping up to be his biggest challenge yet by

far and why does he need to make a special move to save someone when he has the most balanced quirk in the entire series along wit all for one :francis: the


others need to do that because they dont have an amazing quirk like him and he has done a lot of stuuf in the series such as saving Tenya from Stain or Kota from

the muscle dude and becoming Kota's All Might :wow: and also he defeated Overhaul who was a main villain so what do u mean he hasnt done shyt in



comparison lmao hes easily the most accomplished in his class despite not being the strongest. U makin up false narratives because u dont like him which aint


fair if u discussing his role and purpose in the story :stopitslime: we can talk bout him objectively
 

42 Monks

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 20, 2014
Messages
56,419
Reputation
9,500
Daps
209,562
Reppin
Carolina
Deku has his own regrets like when him and Mirio aint save Eri initially or when he couldnt save Bakugo but this arc is shaping up to be his biggest challenge yet by

far and why does he need to make a special move to save someone when he has the most balanced quirk in the entire series along wit all for one :francis: the


others need to do that because they dont have an amazing quirk like him and he has done a lot of stuuf in the series such as saving Tenya from Stain or Kota from

the muscle dude and becoming Kota's All Might :wow: and also he defeated Overhaul who was a main villain so what do u mean he hasnt done shyt in



comparison lmao hes easily the most accomplished in his class despite not being the strongest. U makin up false narratives because u dont like him which aint


fair if u discussing his role and purpose in the story :stopitslime: we can talk bout him objectively
You comparing a bad day at work and a mission accomplished to all the people All Might has seen die in front of him over a career proves that you're the one not talking about this objectively.

"Why does he need to work on moves to save someone?" Cmon. This is in response to yal pushing this idea that he's working to save people like that's his thing. Deku been working on knocking people the fukk out and out maneuvering his opponents exclusively breh. Saving people is a byproduct of handing out fades to Deku. Lets not twist this up. Deku is trying to hit goons harder than anyone in the business.

Giving him the win for Stain when Stain wasn't even going hard and it was a whole team of people :dead: beat overhaul when he literally got paired with the one person on earth who wouldn't let him suicide for the win :dead:

yal trying to wish a character into existence
 

brickflair

All Star
Joined
Jan 24, 2016
Messages
1,315
Reputation
242
Daps
4,906
Reppin
Queens, NY
1.) Mirio was born with a Quirk that literally broke his own Father and his dreams of becoming a Hero because of how impossible it was to master. His Father passed down a Quirk that could kill him upon activation. As a child, he could have died each. time. he used it. Compare the millions of times he's faced literal death trying to get a handle on his power, WITHOUT A MENTOR or any sort of guidance, prior to even getting into UA with Deku. Now flip the difficulty level to 100 to turn that same Quirk into one that makes you a Top Hero Prospect at the most prestigious School and a hair away from being All Might's successor.

All Might said he would have given it to Mirio if he hadn't ran into Deku by accident. So all the qualities you listed as reasons Deku was chosen also apply to Mirio and he's a harder worker, with greater character that actually makes the people around him better. He makes them laugh, they look up to him, he makes them strive to be better, & even after losing his Quirk & his Father figure he's more upbeat and energized than Deku with One for All.

Mirio is a better character. Period.

2.) Asta was also born without powers in a world where even the lowliest peasant has some magical ability. In Deku's world there's still a percentage of the global population that doesn't have a Quirk. In Asta's, it's unheard of, so he's born into a worse situation off rip.

Despite this & without even the parents Deku had, Asta never wavered. Ran the fade with whole adults as a kid, chased MILF nuns, & took on his prodigal foster brother as a rival all without any abilities. He also trained his body physically to the peak in anticipation of achieving his goal and once he finally got his book, he put all that built up hard work to use. Deku hadn't trained a day in his life until All Might handed him power.

If he had Asta's drive, he wouldn't be crippling himself because he would have prepared his body.

Try again. :unimpressed:
Deku did train his body intensely jus to barely scratch the surface of one for all also Deku has had little to no time in comparison to Mirio whos a couple years older,


Deku is in progress to become the greatest hero yes Mirio is a better hero but Deku's biggest strength is influence as he's constantly had impact on others who


doubt him even more so than Mirio, this the same person who risked everything to save Uraraka for an entrance exam yes Mirio put himself in constant danger


but so has Deku in way more high pressure situations as a first year. Todoroki literally became stronger because of Deku's words if not for him hed jus be using his


ice powers. Asta being a meathead doesnt mean he has more conviction than Deku i think its more impressive bein as scared as Deku was and can be at times


that he never once runs away
 

brickflair

All Star
Joined
Jan 24, 2016
Messages
1,315
Reputation
242
Daps
4,906
Reppin
Queens, NY
You comparing a bad day at work and a mission accomplished to all the people All Might has seen die in front of him over a career proves that you're the one not talking about this objectively.

"Why does he need to work on moves to save someone?" Cmon. This is in response to yal pushing this idea that he's working to save people like that's his thing. Deku been working on knocking people the fukk out and out maneuvering his opponents exclusively breh. Saving people is a byproduct of handing out fades to Deku. Lets not twist this up. Deku is trying to hit goons harder than anyone in the business.

Giving him the win for Stain when Stain wasn't even going hard and it was a whole team of people :dead: beat overhaul when he literally got paired with the one person on earth who wouldn't let him suicide for the win :dead:

yal trying to wish a character into existence
All Might has had decades as a hero, Deku has bout a year and a half as one in training I gave u a reason why he doesnt need to work on moves because one for

all literally gives super strength on a ridiculous level at jus 20% and yes imma give him the win for Stain because Stain himself gave him his blessing as a true hero,

Stain's beauty is that he is challenging the notion of heroes and here Deku is living up to the standard he finds acceptable. U cant take away his victory cause u dont

like how its handled it legit makes sense and u jus dont like it for ya own reasons but for me its beautiful that while Eri cant 1v1 Overhaul she still played a major part

in takin down her abuser
 

brickflair

All Star
Joined
Jan 24, 2016
Messages
1,315
Reputation
242
Daps
4,906
Reppin
Queens, NY
All I needed to hear. :yeshrug:

Kinda disappointed to see you ignore the evidence in Asta's favor and distilled it down to "meathead" but you can't win them all.

:ehh:
I said meathead as trope definition not really a negative, the way Asta and Deku approach issues is very different cause they got very different personalities u


appreciate Asta more for it I like Deku more even tho I aint all the way caught up to Black Clover. Even tho Mirio is abetter hero imo i jus like Deku and his timidness

more because its an interesting dichotomy wit how powerful his quirk is
 

LordDeathwatch

Valar Morghulis
Supporter
Joined
Feb 10, 2017
Messages
14,728
Reputation
12,202
Daps
73,226
Reppin
Baltimore, MD / Charlotte, NC
Mirio is dope as hell.

To turn THAT quirk into something so powerful? :wow:

tenor.gif












340
:mjgrin:
 

Sterling Archer

Spider Mane
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
35,120
Reputation
10,938
Daps
172,273
Reppin
Chicago
I think when they had the second fight deku really stepped into his own... Could have literally obliterated bakugo if he wanted and almost took his head off with that back spinning roundhouse...:wow:

There was an episode where they showed how bakugo was raised and you could see why he's always fukked up and angry. Deku/midoriya was always trying to be friends with this cat when he was a kid :scust:but no one taught him self respect even though he was quirkless. Mad people are like that IRL until they snap... :ufdup: I'm glad he's not trying to even be friends with that angry ass fool...:heh:stay mad bakugo...:umad:
Deku and Bakugo fought all out in that second fight. There is no “could’ve” in that outcome. Once Midoriya saw that Bakugo wasn’t going to be talked out the fight, he was fully into it. The outcome was what it was supposed to be. At that moment Bakugo is still a little stronger than Midoriya. And the problems that they have with each other come out in that fight. Midoriya fully understands why Bakugo hates him even though it’s incorrect. Bakugo giving him advice on how to fight after their moment with Almight has moved their relationship forward tremendously. They just haven’t had a chance to show it yet because the next arc focuses on The League.
 
Top