Mount Rushmore of Qbs

[Freestyle Phantom3.0]

Brady
Graham
Montana
Unitas

 

[feelosofer]

Montana
Bradshaw
Unitas
Peyton Manning

 

[Darts]

Tom Brady will be the greatest QB of all time when he retires. Done deal.

 

[Bboystyle]

Right now:

Montana
Marino
Elway
Unitas






10 years from now:
Rodgers
Brady
Montana
Peyton Manning

 

[No1]

The thing about Mt. Rushmore, are you talking influence or just greatest? That's why I can see Graham and Johnny U.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Vescey no disrespect but you sound completely nonsensical. The idea that there are 7 QBs in history better than Tom Brady is one of the dumbest things ever uttered on this board. This dude said Roger Staubauch.

Name me these 7 QBs better than Brady. I'll spot you Montana and that's really all you get.

If anything Brady is getting disrespected in this thread. LOL@Elway over Brady in any sensible human being's mind.

Answer me this. Have you seen Staubach play?

Is Jordan the best B-Ball player ever?

The truth aint gon make sense to people nowadays so I'll accept that

 

[MoneyBags]

why is manning up there ?

ya'll nikkas drinkin the same water ?
this nikka only got one ring. why the fukk he so special

his lil bro has 2, why we ain't talkin about him

i kinda agree. i don't see how you can put one ring manning over a 3 ring brady.

 

[No1]

Answer me this. Have you seen Staubach play?

Is Jordan the best B-Ball player ever?

The truth aint gon make sense to people nowadays so I'll accept that

Answer my question, name 7 quarterbacks better than Tom Brady and your basis. I'll wait.

 

[DuncanWebayama]

how is manning ahead of brady?

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Answer my question, name 7 quarterbacks better than Tom Brady and your basis. I'll wait.

So this means no. You've never seen Staubach play. Now why should I take you seriously again? Its fooilish and dangerous to offer insight on something you know absolutely nothing about.

Half of the cats in here have never seen Super Joe or Elway play, but they got them in their top 5 and its simply due to media programming and has nothing to do with an informed opinion.


You can't refute something you've never seen or heard of. Its like you're arguing for the sake of arguing. That's kind of feminine.

 

[No1]

So this means no. You've never seen Staubach play. Now why should I take you seriously again? Its fooilish and dangerous to offer insight on something you know absolutely nothing about.

Half of the cats in here have never seen Super Joe or Elway play, but they got them in their top 5 and its simply due to media programming and has nothing to do with an informed opinion.


You can't refute something you've never seen or heard of. Its like you're arguing for the sake of arguing. That's kind of feminine.

All right, so let me guess this straight. You sit here like a fool and say that Tom Brady has 7 QBs better than him. Then when asked to name them, you turn around and answer me with another question? And then you think that you've proven a point because I'm pulling your card? I'm not saying anything until you answer the question.

But you can't and that's what's hilarious. You're going off of just purely who you like or foolish nostalgia or whatever motivates people who don't know what they're talking about. The thing is, we did see Joe play, we did see Elway play. Then we went back and looked at their numbers in the context of their teams and eras. Elway doesn't stack up.

We've had literal 20 page threads on Elway being overrated. Trust me breh, I just want that list.

 

[Street Knowledge]

nikkaz now are just Openly hating on Brady. It's disgusting

How a guy who Has

- the highest winning percentage in NFL history (78% regular season and 75% postseason)
-has comparable, if not better, per game numbers than Manning and Marino...
-not to mention he has 3 Super Bowls(2 SB MVP's)and 16 career postseason victories and only Montana is better with 4 Super Bowls and 16 career postseason wins.
- arguably the most dominant single season ('07) and most efficient single season ('10) in NFL history. 2 League MVP's
-Has converted 24 of 34 comeback opportunities in his career (71%), which is the best in NFL history. And his touchdown-to-interception ratio (2.6) is the best in NFL history among all players with 2,000 or more passing attempts

Is not on the mount rush more of QB's is blasphemous. Just say you don't like the nikka and move on

 

[THE MACHINE]

Fixed that for you before your parents saw it. Don't want you to get in trouble for saying something stupid.

God knows you wouldn't gauge or pass judgement on something you've never seen before just to validate something that you're more intimate with...Right?

You've seen Staubach? I doubt it, but yet you pass judgement on him to validate something/someone you're slightly familiar with. Isn't that what you were accusing me of? Giving someone more benefit because of nostalgia or some type of yearning for yesteryear, all because of familiarity. I've seen both play so logically speaking, my opinion should carry more weight right? Its simple logic correct?

You've only seen one of them play more than likely, but yet you believe your opinion should carry more weight.

I sware we aint gon make it as a country

No list of those 7 quarterbacks yet huh?

We all make judgements based on what we know but it appears that you wont throw yours out to be criticized. You have built up an image of yourself in your own mind and its laughable to others. I am 29 and have seen Elway, Montana, Young, Marino, Manning, Moon, Favre live and have seen film/highlights on others and deem Brady to be better than all of those with the exception of Montana, and even thats debatable at this point. For you to say he won mainly because of a kicker and a defense shows you have either no knowledge of football, havent watched the Patriots the last decade or an ulterior motive. By the way, games that end with a kicker making a kick are also called "Game Winning Drives." Everyone who has seen them play knows they have been an offensive juggernaut for the majority of his tenure while throwing to David Patten, Welker, Deion Branch etc. He is 16-6 in the playoffs.

Now how about that list.

 

[THE MACHINE]

nikkaz now are just Openly hating on Brady. It's disgusting

How a guy who Has

- the highest winning percentage in NFL history (78% regular season and 75% postseason)
-has comparable, if not better, per game numbers than Manning and Marino...
-not to mention he has 3 Super Bowls(2 SB MVP's)and 16 career postseason victories and only Montana is better with 4 Super Bowls and 16 career postseason wins.
- arguably the most dominant single season ('07) and most efficient single season ('10) in NFL history. 2 League MVP's
-Has converted 24 of 34 comeback opportunities in his career (71%), which is the best in NFL history. And his touchdown-to-interception ratio (2.6) is the best in NFL history among all players with 2,000 or more passing attempts

Is not on the mount rush more of QB's is blasphemous. Just say you don't like the nikka and move on

Facts dont seem to matter in here.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

All right, so let me guess this straight. You sit here like a fool and say that Tom Brady has 7 QBs better than him. Then when asked to name them, you turn around and answer me with another question? And then you think that you've proven a point because I'm pulling your card? I'm not saying anything until you answer the question.

But you can't and that's what's hilarious. You're going off of just purely who you like or foolish nostalgia or whatever motivates people who don't know what they're talking about. The thing is, we did see Joe play, we did see Elway play. Then we went back and looked at their numbers in the context of their teams and eras. Elway doesn't stack up.

We've had literal 20 page threads on Elway being overrated. Trust me breh, I just want that list.

The no child left behind act has failed you miserably, and its not your fault. Again, what makes you "qualified" to comment on something you know absolutely nothing about. Its like telling me a movie sucks but you've never ever seen it.

The question at hand pertains to GOAT QBs, not top QBs over the last 20 years, correct?

Peyton
Super Joe
Elway
Dan Marino
Staubach
Johnny Unitas and wait for it......
Steve Young

I know a whole bunch of football heads that would even take Brett Favre over Brady.

Now get on google and counter with your out of "context" stats