Isaiah Bradley
Banned
Ummmm some breeds of dog were bred doing nothing but mating for physical characterstics. If something worked then they kept doing it. They didnt need to know the exact science behind it.
The problem with the human breeding argument is that it wasnt done on a scale widespread enough and long enough to be responsible for increased athleticism. A couple slave owners in a state wouldnt be able to change the genetics of African Americans country wide.
but the dog breeding also produced non-ideal results for the human dog breeder. I think it's safe to suggest that there were more "failures" than "success" when randomly breeding dogs without proper knowledge
The scale of the "slave breeding" is my knockout punch in these kind of discussions. But before going to that, you have to set it up correctly by clearly proving how lazy in rational the other person is and how much the other person lacks perspective and understanding on the subject matter
Again, most folks, especially black, don't have a detailed grasp of black history, especially if the topic is not about slavery or civil rights