I agree with you, but here's what happened in public opinion:
Tical followed the sound of 36 Chambers while Dirty Version, Cuban Linx, Liquid Swords & Ironman all did their own thing.
Method Man, while the standout MC of the group, had the weakest debut while everyone else came stronger and even Meth himself had better performances on group guest spots & outsider guest spots in the next few years than his own debut album.
Lastly, its most known song only exists in two off-album versions, both of which supersede the album version as superior songs.
So I think it's more of those who heard it in its time that can recognize the classic nature of the album as opposed to those who hear it in the context of the catalog.