Meccapolis ranks “Kings Of New York” from 1985 to 2024

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
60,815
Reputation
8,147
Daps
193,728
Reppin
BX, NYC
Jay sold more but Kingdom Come is universally seen as a weak album and Jay was forced to course correct with American Gangster. Both Hip Hop Is Dead and Fishscale were held in higher regard during that time period.

Jim Jones as king of anything is laughable
None of this matters it’s about what the city feels

With Kingdom Come the king returned

Jim Jones in 2006 also was the man maybe to “real hip hop heads” and out of towners he ain’t shyt

Nas and GFK weren’t in the running they had lost that local cultural relevance and influence
 

mikishere

#byrdgang
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
10,805
Reputation
2,555
Daps
34,541
Reppin
NYC
im a max b stan and he 100% deserves to be a finalist for 08 and 09, but KONY? :patrice:

i will say that max had the streets of NY more than ANY rapper both of those years though, especially uptown. realistically though, the only correct answer is hov for 09, and the fact he isnt a finalist but washed/flopping 50 CENT is :dead:.

hov is also 2006 easily as well
 

Kliq_Souf

Superstar
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
13,841
Reputation
3,033
Daps
39,280
Reppin
WOL
50 shouldn't have any year after 2005, his run was basically over after losing the sales battle to Kanye
Cam in '06... idk man. Cam should have a year for sure, but 06? I like Killa Season too

Max B for 2 years? :dead:
 

A Tribe Called Quest ™

Make Em Say Ughh ... Silk da Shocker
Joined
Jul 28, 2013
Messages
18,095
Reputation
-1,173
Daps
44,386
Reppin
Chiraq
Curtis came out 4Q 2007 and still had massive sales

fukk it his best work quality wise was behind him but he was still a superstar there was no contenders so he gets it by default
I get it but overall when you think of the year 08 you think of Wayne/TI/Jeezy/Game/Ye
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
60,815
Reputation
8,147
Daps
193,728
Reppin
BX, NYC
50 shouldn't have any year after 2005, his run was basically over after losing the sales battle to Kanye
Cam in '06... idk man. Cam should have a year for sure, but 06? I like Killa Season too

Max B for 2 years? :dead:
That was in ‘07 almost ‘08 and he sold 691,000 copies first week :heh:
 

mikishere

#byrdgang
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
10,805
Reputation
2,555
Daps
34,541
Reppin
NYC
Curtis came out 4Q 2007 and still had massive sales

fukk it his best work quality wise was behind him but he was still a superstar there was no contenders so he gets it by default

ehh, curtis came and went. plus the album being so bad pretty much put his career in the coffin. nobody was playing that shyt in 2008 lol. only capped out at platinum after doing massive first week sales.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
60,815
Reputation
8,147
Daps
193,728
Reppin
BX, NYC
ehh, curtis came and went. plus the album being so bad pretty much put his career in the coffin. nobody was playing that shyt in 2008 lol. only capped out at platinum after doing massive first week sales.
Yeah I know but if not 50 who

It’s 50 or Jay by default
 
Last edited:
Top