Nah. Dont agree wit this. Lu is def an elite lyricist. Him an Kendrick arent the same at all lyrically. And thats fine. A song like SLR3 shows this. And that aint even the best example. Kendrick is just far more consistent musically. And has the ability to captivate people in ways Lupe cant.
They aren't the same, I never once said they had similar writing styles or song structure or anything
of that nature. Kendrick is clearly in another stratosphere to Lupe when it comes to that.
However as far as Lupe being an "Elite Lyricist", I don't disagree I just don't agree with the idea that
Kendrick isn't "Elite" as well. I think Kendrick's simplicity is overstated here and he's often depicted
as some incoherent rambler who makes no points or says nothing. Somehow he confuses
and bamboozles some of his detractors on The Coli but makes perfect sense to the general public.
Clearly, there's some dishonesty here (that's not necessarily aimed at you obviously) but there's a
theme that goes along with people dismissing Kendrick Lamar as the "ranting and raving incoherent
media darling" which is something repeated on here often.
With that said you mention SLR3 but that's just the thing songs like SLR3, Form Follows Function, Lupe The Killer, Mural etc.
are just a small bit of his body of work. That vast majority of his material doesn't follow that "Lyrical Exercise" format.
Paris, Tokyo and Hurt Me Soul and other songs of that nature aren't brilliant because they're incredible
literary works delivered in a Hip-Hop format, they're great because essentially they function well as songs.
The lyrics themselves aren't some mind blowing shyt, they're pretty normal and use a lot of the same literary
devices that Lupe's peers use.
Kendrick isn't averse to metaphor.
J. Cole isn't new to Punchlines.
Royce Da 5'9" can weave a coherent story as well as anyone.
Skyzoo snaps together all kinds of cultural references, metaphors and open ended
musings into his music that'd make Lupe himself blush.
And Elzhi well...he's Elzhi.
What Lupe regularly does is pretty typical of the better writers in Hip-Hop and what annoys me
is instead of focusing on Lyrics and really conversing about Lyrics a lot of posters on here would
rather turn to slobbing off their favorite rapper, which is cool but I think that's when the discussion
turns from Hip-Hop and the writing therein to hero worship.
I think Kendrick's great and I'm often pegged as a Kendrick "stan" but whenever I enter these threads
I make sure to mention that I think several other rappers are great and they aren't always 90's heroes
they're usually contemporary artists
.
Which leads to this :
At some point I have to ask,"how does anyone who has a genuine love for writing or it's place in
Hip-Hop think Lupe fiasco stands alone ?".