Lupe Fiasco “kendrick is not a top tier lyricist to me”

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
62,145
Reputation
9,512
Daps
206,941
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
Popping like anything. On any level.

And like it or not popularity goes hand in hand with whether or not people are checking for an artist. You cats are making this shyt 100x more complicated than it needs to be....I been into rap since 1984....let's say, during the 90's for example....Pac, BONE, Wu, Outkast, Nas, Death Row, BIG, etc. was the popular artists.

Ras Kass wasn't selling 5 mill. Com's "Resurrection" wasn't going diamond.The most lyrical cats wasn't running anything....it was the people that could craft the best music. And by Lupe's own admission, he's lacking in that regard....which is cool, there's different lanes....but instead of accepting that his music is niche, and as such is only going to reach a limited amount of people....you want to assume people don't understand the "allegorical imagery". Which is, to be blunt, fukking silly. It's the exact same argument as "you don't listen to (insert popular artist), you don't get p*ssy"....just on the opposite end of the spectrum.

Fred.
Bro Lupe has charting singles and albums. Grammy noms. All that. nikkas actin like the nikka always been some underground artist. Lol
 

hex

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
38,509
Reputation
19,130
Daps
196,484
Drake didnt drop an album in 2017 but Views alone outsold anything kendrick put out

And if it’s always “talent” with kendrick, why kendrick stans in here talking about who more popular? Cause that works in their favor when it comes to Lu. Stan talk 101.

Tetsuo and youth was a strong album with strong concepts, hell kendrick even grabbed some ideas from it for damn.

Drake didn't drop an album in 2017....what the fukk was "More Life"?

And don't come with that play list bullshyt.

"Views" was a pop album. The biggest hits of Drake's career ain't even rap. The biggest hits of Kendrick's career are RAP. Cut the bullshyt out. People compare Kendrick and Lupe because they're both rappers....same as people compare any rappers....and Kendrick fans been talking about his popularity since "DAMN" dropped because it blew the fukk up. It has nothing to do with Lupe specifically.


Why do you Lupe fans over complicate everything? I said "it WAS always his talent". Key word....was. Now he actually has the sales so his fans bring that up, too. It's not rocket science. And we have no way of knowing if TDE stole ideas from Lupe....if it stopped at "T&Y" I might be able to rock with the theory....but now Lupe is claiming they stole his album cover....where does this shyt stop?

I need you cats to understand I don't even fukk with Kendrick like that. Go check the "TPAB" thread, I was one of the few people criticizing it. So imagine how out of touch some of yall sound....for someone like me to actually defend him.

Fred.
 

hex

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
38,509
Reputation
19,130
Daps
196,484
Bro Lupe has charting singles and albums. Grammy noms. All that. nikkas actin like the nikka always been some underground artist. Lol


I specifically said the more lyrical, abstract shyt Lupe has done recently. Which ain't setting the world on fire like that. The last gold album he had was "Lasers" which was terrible. His last plat single came out 6 years ago, for Christ sake.

Again....by his own admission he don't care about making the best music anymore, just crafting the best bars. Which is cool but his music has suffered because of it.

Fred.

Fred.
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
62,145
Reputation
9,512
Daps
206,941
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
:snoop:

I never said anything about people never fukking with Lupe. I never said anything remotely similar to that.

I specifically said the more lyrical, abstract shyt Lupe has done recently. Which ain't setting the world on fire like that. The last gold album he had was "Lasers" which was terrible. His last plat single came out 6 years ago, for Christ sake.

Again....by his own admission he don't care about making the best music anymore, just crafting the best bars. Which is cool but his music has suffered because of it.



This angle don't work anymore as Kendrick outsold and got more critical acclaim than Drake in 2017. Hell, even prior to that Kendrick had the critical acclaim and Drake had sales, so there was always a division (prior to 2017, anyway) as to what their respective fan bases could brag about. And with Kendrick, it was always his talent. Drake, it was his numbers.

Fred.
Lupe says shyt like that cause he’s a sore loser. Lets keep it 100. The nikka was bragging HARD about T&Y. And how great an album it was. And imo. It was the best album that dropped that year. And its not cause of the lyrics alone. Its cause I felt it was dope music. And it was dope concepts executed properly. Even the concept that Kenny used for DAMN! where u play the album backwards. Lupe did that flawlessly with T&Y already. And this is coming from a nikka who felt every album that nikka put out since The Cool was trash. Lupe def got looked over for that album and he’s DEF salty about it. So he resorts to that kid tactic acting like shyt dont matter at all.
 

hex

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
38,509
Reputation
19,130
Daps
196,484
Lupe says shyt like that cause he’s a sore loser. Lets keep it 100. The nikka was bragging HARD about T&Y. And how great an album it was. And imo. It was the best album that dropped that year. And its not cause of the lyrics alone. Its cause I felt it was dope music. And it was dope concepts executed properly. Even the concept that Kenny used for DAMN! where u play the album backwards. Lupe did that flawlessly with T&Y already. And this is coming from a nikka who felt every album that nikka put out since The Cool was trash.

I said, that alone....I could entertain the thought that maybe they stole his idea. But then he doubled down and is now claiming they stole his album cover. He's out here sounding like a lunatic.

Regardless of his logic....whether or not he's a sore loser or whatever....the end result is still the same. He has little to no interest in making actual music. When I see him promoting shyt like MF DOOM and Aesop Rock. Talking about they're the GOATs or the best out or whatever. I think he probably went the "full bars, no musicality" route as a defense mechanism because his shyt wasn't popping how he thought it would....but I 100% think he's serious with it.

Fred.
 

Dboy41

All Star
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
1,363
Reputation
155
Daps
3,795
Drake didn't drop an album in 2017....what the fukk was "More Life"?

And don't come with that play list bullshyt.

"Views" was a pop album. The biggest hits of Drake's career ain't even rap. The biggest hits of Kendrick's career are RAP. Cut the bullshyt out. People compare Kendrick and Lupe because they're both rappers....same as people compare any rappers....and Kendrick fans been talking about his popularity since "DAMN" dropped because it blew the fukk up. It has nothing to do with Lupe specifically.


Why do you Lupe fans over complicate everything? I said "it WAS always his talent". Key word....was. Now he actually has the sales so his fans bring that up, too. It's not rocket science. And we have no way of knowing if TDE stole ideas from Lupe....if it stopped at "T&Y" I might be able to rock with the theory....but now Lupe is claiming they stole his album cover....where does this shyt stop?

I need you cats to understand I don't even fukk with Kendrick like that. Go check the "TPAB" thread, I was one of the few people criticizing it. So imagine how out of touch some of yall sound....for someone like me to actually defend him.

Fred.
Caught ya...... more life wasnt an album it was a mixtape...

Dont pull that “drake is pop so he sells more” bullshyt when y’all was in here big talking about sales and popularity lol. Thats all im saying. The arguments and logic change when it works in your favor. Besides kendrick working with rihanna, he pop now too lol.
 

Insensitive

Superstar
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
12,375
Reputation
4,746
Daps
41,903
Reppin
NULL
What I don't understand about Lupe fiasco or more specifically his stans
is why the discussion about Lupe fiasco is that this dude always writes
these mind blowing unbelievable deeply abstract and hard to understand verses.

Like 90% of his discography if we're looking at the lyrics they really aren't all that special.
I'd even argue they're much in line with what other lyricists have brought to the table.
What makes Lupe great isn't some next level lyrical skill, it was cool song concepts
The Cool, Food & Liquor and Tetsuo & Youth are great albums because of that IMO.

Cause if we're being really real Lupe's discography is largely very accessible when it comes
to the writing and not to different from Kendrick to be honest.

He isn't exactly Aesop Rock or El-P or Saul Williams or even Blu who regularly writes
some of the most painterly wonderfully craftedlyrics that are always accented by his
choice of samples. Perfect example of this is "H.E.R. favorite Colo(u)r".
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
62,145
Reputation
9,512
Daps
206,941
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
What I don't understand about Lupe fiasco or more specifically his stans
is why the discussion about Lupe fiasco is that this dude always writes
these mind blowing unbelievable deeply abstract and hard to understand verses.

Like 90% of his discography if we're looking at the lyrics they really aren't all that special.
I'd even argue they're much in line with what other lyricists have brought to the table.
What makes Lupe great isn't some next level lyrical skill, it was cool song concepts
The Cool, Food & Liquor and Tetsuo & Youth are great albums because of that IMO.

Cause if we're being really real Lupe's discography is largely very accessible when it comes
to the writing and not to different from Kendrick to be honest.

He isn't exactly Aesop Rock or El-P or Saul Williams or even Blu who regularly writes
some of the most painterly wonderfully craftedlyrics that are always accented by his
choice of samples. Perfect example of this is "H.E.R. favorite Colo(u)r".
Nah. Dont agree wit this. Lu is def an elite lyricist. Him an Kendrick arent the same at all lyrically. And thats fine. A song like SLR3 shows this. And that aint even the best example. Kendrick is just far more consistent musically. And has the ability to captivate people in ways Lupe cant.
 

Insensitive

Superstar
Joined
May 21, 2012
Messages
12,375
Reputation
4,746
Daps
41,903
Reppin
NULL
Nah. Dont agree wit this. Lu is def an elite lyricist. Him an Kendrick arent the same at all lyrically. And thats fine. A song like SLR3 shows this. And that aint even the best example. Kendrick is just far more consistent musically. And has the ability to captivate people in ways Lupe cant.
They aren't the same, I never once said they had similar writing styles or song structure or anything
of that nature. Kendrick is clearly in another stratosphere to Lupe when it comes to that.

However as far as Lupe being an "Elite Lyricist", I don't disagree I just don't agree with the idea that
Kendrick isn't "Elite" as well. I think Kendrick's simplicity is overstated here and he's often depicted
as some incoherent rambler who makes no points or says nothing. Somehow he confuses
and bamboozles some of his detractors on The Coli but makes perfect sense to the general public.

Clearly, there's some dishonesty here (that's not necessarily aimed at you obviously) but there's a
theme that goes along with people dismissing Kendrick Lamar as the "ranting and raving incoherent
media darling" which is something repeated on here often.


With that said you mention SLR3 but that's just the thing songs like SLR3, Form Follows Function, Lupe The Killer, Mural etc.
are just a small bit of his body of work. That vast majority of his material doesn't follow that "Lyrical Exercise" format.

Paris, Tokyo and Hurt Me Soul and other songs of that nature aren't brilliant because they're incredible
literary works delivered in a Hip-Hop format, they're great because essentially they function well as songs.
The lyrics themselves aren't some mind blowing shyt, they're pretty normal and use a lot of the same literary
devices that Lupe's peers use.

Kendrick isn't averse to metaphor.
J. Cole isn't new to Punchlines.
Royce Da 5'9" can weave a coherent story as well as anyone.
Skyzoo snaps together all kinds of cultural references, metaphors and open ended
musings into his music that'd make Lupe himself blush.
And Elzhi well...he's Elzhi.

What Lupe regularly does is pretty typical of the better writers in Hip-Hop and what annoys me
is instead of focusing on Lyrics and really conversing about Lyrics a lot of posters on here would
rather turn to slobbing off their favorite rapper, which is cool but I think that's when the discussion
turns from Hip-Hop and the writing therein to hero worship.

I think Kendrick's great and I'm often pegged as a Kendrick "stan" but whenever I enter these threads
I make sure to mention that I think several other rappers are great and they aren't always 90's heroes
they're usually contemporary artists
.
Which leads to this :
At some point I have to ask,"how does anyone who has a genuine love for writing or it's place in
Hip-Hop think Lupe fiasco stands alone ?".
 
Top