I've been in a similar situation to this so i can somewhat understand Clays mindset.
I dated this chick similar to AD. She looked good with makeup but without she was a different person, average looking but had an amazing body and to this day has been the only women that could be naked/semi-hard and i would get hard instantly (no need to think about it or have foreplay.. i'd just be ready to go)
...and her box was the best i've ever had
She was also submissive, would cook for me and had wifey attributes.
I didn't lock it down though and eventually broke it up with her for the one reason being that i knew i would still be eyeing up and wanting to be with other women, especially women i knew i could attract that were better looking then her and i didn't want to be that guy or put myself in that situation
Looking back i did the right thing but ngl, i do look back and reminecse about her. I'm more mature now and knowing what i know i probably would make more of an effort if i met and started dating her today.