LIVE from Detroit ... the 2024 Official NFL Draft Thread (April 25-27) 6PM EST, ABC/ESPN/NFL Network

Do the Bears take Caleb #1?


  • Total voters
    43
  • Poll closed .

Brozay

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,851
Reputation
7,081
Daps
180,289
not good handling adversity, has clear skills but everything needs to be laid out perfectly for his teams to succeed. His school also doesn't do him any favors.
I dont know enough about him as a person to say this definitively - are we basing this on when we ran to his mom after a loss or didnt honor his media requirements after a loss? or based on actual feedback from coaches, people that have been in the locker room with him? there has been a lot of conjecture here but he has done himself favors with some of his actions

the maturity issues are a bit worrisome, but thats the job of Poles to sort through. I can really only go on what hes put on tape here and his arm talent & awareness is off the charts
 

Dr. Narcisse

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2014
Messages
50,857
Reputation
11,532
Daps
168,214
I mean I can see Justin failing if Eberflus is a disaster this season and they make a poor coaching hire afterwards.

To me Caleb really needs structure. If someone can get him to take the layups and get more in rhythm he can be great. Its imperative that his mobility really does translate to prime Russell Wilson though.
 

Brozay

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,851
Reputation
7,081
Daps
180,289
I mean I can see Justin failing if Eberflus is a disaster this season and they make a poor coaching hire afterwards.

To me Caleb really needs structure. If someone can get him to take the layups and get more in rhythm he can be great. Its imperative that his mobility really does translate to prime Russell Wilson though.
his awareness and ability to navigate a pocket is high
 

Brozay

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,851
Reputation
7,081
Daps
180,289
also if Calebs maturity and ability to play through adversity was a problem this past year at USC, Im happy we didnt reunite him with Kliff like many Bears fans wanted. Doesnt sound like he developed him much as a leader then

one thing Justin has done well with, is lead a locker room and stay very level headed. If they replace him with Caleb, he needs to figure out how to be a pro quickly
 

Dr. Narcisse

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2014
Messages
50,857
Reputation
11,532
Daps
168,214
The Caleb thing is simple to me. If the pocket movement translates he won't miss. If it doesn't he will fail.
Yep.

It is interesting to see what translates to the pros and what doesnt. People were down on Mahomes because they thought what he was doing wouldnt work in the NFL.

Johnny Manziel was eating off the Russell Wilson hype. However, he just wasnt fast or quick enough (on the NFL level) to overcome his below average arm.
 

IIVI

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
11,399
Reputation
2,687
Daps
38,495
Reppin
Los Angeles
I dont know enough about him as a person to say this definitively - are we basing this on when we ran to his mom after a loss or didnt honor his media requirements after a loss? or based on actual feedback from coaches, people that have been in the locker room with him? there has been a lot of conjecture here but he has done himself favors with some of his actions

the maturity issues are a bit worrisome, but thats the job of Poles to sort through. I can really only go on what hes put on tape here and his arm talent & awareness is off the charts
Some good insight I read about him recently:

Perhaps the biggest reason why those who have coached Williams believe he ultimately won’t shy away from being a Chicago Bear, is because he has never shied away from competition.

Williams was not handed the starting job at Gonzaga. He had to compete with two upperclassmen (one of whom went on to play lacrosse at Penn State) and wasn’t named the starter until right before his freshman season began. And when Williams went to Oklahoma, he knew the path to starting right away was blocked by Spencer Rattler, who at the time was the Heisman Trophy favorite. Williams started the 2021 season on the bench before taking over for Rattler in the middle of the Red River Rivalry, leading OU to an improbable comeback win over Texas.

Facing challenging situations is nothing new for Williams, and succeeding as a Chicago Bears quarterback is certainly a challenge.
So when people say he's questionable "handling adversity", that's also absolutely false. Dude has gone for the higher challenge his whole life.
 
Last edited:

Brozay

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,851
Reputation
7,081
Daps
180,289
The Caleb thing is simple to me. If the pocket movement translates he won't miss. If it doesn't he will fail.
I agree with this. I think he processes quickly and has good awareness. He might need to reign it in in the NFL but the reason he holds the ball and extends his time holding the ball is because he’s looking to make a play, not because he can’t see the field well
 

Brozay

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,851
Reputation
7,081
Daps
180,289

Nabers will be a crazy weapon, hes prob the best WR prospect since Chase outside of MHJ whos in his same class

LSU is just turning out crazy WR talent right now - Brian Thomas JR might crush the combine
 

Captain Crunch

Veteran
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
44,365
Reputation
2,429
Daps
112,393
Reppin
NY

I think Miami should extend Tua(a 3 yr Daniel Jones type deal), but draft a qb and have him sit for a year or two.
 
Top