Jimmy 5x all defensive team for one
Sounds like you do. There's other advanced metrics you can quote. But here's the one thing that everyone knows: 1st Team All-NBA isn't an accident.
However the postseason plays out... it is what it is.
Yeah, and I referenced them. PER has proven correlative to player excellence when you contextualize for statistical noise. It's not remotely confusing at this point. Jimmy has 6 seasons with a PER of 23 or higher. Tatum has one. Jimmy has 6 seasons with a WS/48 well over .200. Tatum has none. Tatum has no all defensive teams. Jimmy has 5. Tatum might be as valuable as Jimmy one day. He hasn't been so far.
I have no dog in this fight but one was the 3rd pick in his draft and the other was a 2nd round pick. Tatum has also had better rosters around him than Jimmy has.
![]()
Browns handles denies him of superstardom![]()
This the same site that had folks running around claiming Kuzma & Siakam were better
Those are the type of threads that serve as reminders. This site is funny for fukkery purposes but it's not a real basketball discussion.
Talk about aging like milk (Not Max. The other clown)
I have no dog in this fight but one was the 3rd pick in his draft and the other was a 2nd round pick. Tatum has also had better rosters around him than Jimmy has.
![]()
Tatum would be beloved on here if he played for Charlotte and won 35 games a year