Kendrick Lamar-good kid, m.A.A.d city-2012 (CLASSIC)

Black Ball

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
6,722
Reputation
921
Daps
15,330
Reppin
The Mighty LBC
Of course. This place is littered with impressionable nikkas.

Except for a few things, shyts basically my viewpoint.

It was the equivalent of a excessively-hyped oscar-scaling film used as a platform for 'the next big thing (actor)', and although shyt was technically good... the performance was nothing to write home about, not to say it was run-of-the-mill... but really at no point did he draw me in.

I felt like dude should have just listened to it several times before he gave such a strong opinion on it one way or the other.

Album didn't jump out at me as being super special or classic on my 1st few listens, although I thought it was good. The music/sounds are unique, so you never know how you will vibe with them over time. Just like bangers that grab you on the 1st listen can get real old to a listener real quick. So far this record continues to improve to me with every subsequent listen. You can never know how you will feel about something years down the line, but I don't have a problem calling this piece of work a classic.

I not a big Kendrick fan either, so I understand the boring criticisms and the missing of that star quality criticisms. I definitely felt the same way before this record. Not even really sure that I'll enjoy his next release like I'm sure with other rappers that I love.
 

ECA

Superstar
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
7,670
Reputation
835
Daps
18,748
Reppin
NULL
Added Cartoons and Cereal at the beginning of this, and this shyt is even more next level. The only nikka in recent memory to actually come through on his major label debut.
 

MeachTheMonster

YourFriendlyHoodMonster
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
69,873
Reputation
3,784
Daps
110,026
Reppin
Tha Land
Dude is the new Andre 3000. Critical success, albums flying off the shelves, his peers can't stop gushing about his talent, but he has that rare cult following of haters who are going to be making threads about his voice and clothes and playing the "drop a verse that proves he's lyrical... I'll wait" game for years to come

I feel like this was directed to me so I will respond. First off I always said I liked the cd and it was good music, just not "amazing" as a lot of people on here are saying. As far as his voice, i don't even think it's his voice, just the way he uses some of his words or the random "my nikka"s or "ya bish" just comes of as immature and corny to me. It might just be some west cost stuff but these dudes remind me of the suburban black dudes who tried to be "gangsta" just for fun. The entire story about riding on a nikka in your moms van comes off as corny to me. Growing up if nikkas was robin and shootin it was cause they had to in order to survive, not cause they homies told them to. We didn't have "moms vans" to ride around in. Or parents at home supporting our dreams.

As far as the "post some lyrical lyrics" shyt goes. That was a response to people saying he is an amazing lyricist and better than nas lyrically. So I said prove it and the stans couldn't.

With all that said he is talented this is a good album, great for a debut in today's climate. But not as "amazing" an groundbreaking as his stans make him out to be.
 

Izanami

Superstar
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
12,901
Reputation
1,560
Daps
38,455
Still don't understand how anyone can dislike Section 80. The production was dope and Kendrick killed damn near every track.

ADHD, Rigamortis, Ronald Regean Era, fukk Your Ethnicity, Kiesha Song, Hii Power, Poe Man Dreams, Spiteful Chant...like damn those songs were crafted to perfection.
 

Champ_KW

Superstar
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
6,516
Reputation
1,060
Daps
19,429
Reppin
NULL
Of course. This place is littered with impressionable nikkas.

Except for a few things, shyts basically my viewpoint.

It was the equivalent of a excessively-hyped oscar-scaling film used as a platform for 'the next big thing (actor)', and although shyt was technically good... the performance was nothing to write home about, not to say it was run-of-the-mill... but really at no point did he draw me in.

I don't think this album is getting enough praise, honestly. The reason this cd sits well with me is because it comes from the same honest place that most young black men childhood resides. In any given neighborhood, there are maybe at most 10-15 "stars". Be it D-boys, playas, or athletes. The rest of us are sideline spectators to the world that those few stars live. So it's nothing to be a kid that never banged but understand the codes of your neighborhood. It's nothing to be a good student and come from a decent home yet get involved in smoking weed or doing petty crimes due to your influence from your friends. It's nothing to be a kid who parents actually take an active role in your life and well being (exhibited by the numerous phone calls through out the "day" on the cd) when you see other kids who parents not give a rats ass if they go to school, come in at a decent time, etc. One thing that Bomani said that rang true is that we want our rappers to be stars. I take it to a more honest level and feel that I want my rappers to be better than me (craft wise). Too many times we get records written from the "stars" of the neighborhood perspective. Everybody with a deal just so happens to be the biggest dope dealer his hood ever seen. Kendrick told MY story in a better way (craft wise) than I could even imagine. That's why the album is really good to me.
 

Walt

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
11,360
Reputation
12,159
Daps
69,775
I feel like this was directed to me so I will respond.

Before I read the rest of your post, let me clarify my post wasn't directed at you, it was general, and the "post a verse" shyt has mainly been a way to discredit Andre from Outkast for years now, which creates this Benny Hill type of frenetic goofiness where someone posts a verse they think is dope, then the person who wanted the proof of lyricism simply dismisses the verse and then posts a verse by Biggie or Nas or Prodigy or whomever and says "now that's what a lyrical verse is."

First off I always said I liked the cd and it was good music, just not "amazing" as a lot of people on here are saying. As far as his voice, i don't even think it's his voice, just the way he uses some of his words or the random "my nikka"s or "ya bish" just comes of as immature and corny to me.

I don't actually like that "ya bish" shyt either, nor his Macho Man Randy Savage growl of beeyotch on Backseat Freestyle. I damn near stopped listening to Section 80 the first time I tried as soon as the song "Hol' Up" came on because of the way he was pronouncing that shyt.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

It might just be some west cost stuff but these dudes remind me of the suburban black dudes who tried to be "gangsta" just for fun. The entire story about riding on a nikka in your moms van comes off as corny to me. Growing up if nikkas was robin and shootin it was cause they had to in order to survive, not cause they homies told them to. We didn't have "moms vans" to ride around in. Or parents at home supporting our dreams.

I'd be interested in someone from around Compton verifying whether Kendrick, Q, Ab-Soul, and Jay-Rock are suburban kids. Kendrick definitely has that annoying hipster style, but a lot of hood nikkas have adopted that shyt these days so I can't call it.
@OnlyInCalifornia? @@Megatronbomb? Can someone hood check these nikkas real quick and provide some info?

As far as the "post some lyrical lyrics" shyt goes. That was a response to people saying he is an amazing lyricist and better than nas lyrically. So I said prove it and the stans couldn't.

Oh, the overreaction is amusing to me too. I can't really speak on Nas, because the way cats have put him on a pedestal, Nas ain't even as good as Nas.

With all that said he is talented this is a good album, great for a debut in today's climate. But not as "amazing" an groundbreaking as his stans make him out to be.

I respect that take. If I was directly addressing you I would've quoted you. I didn't even notice who posted "show me a verse" or if it was more than one person to be honest. I've never been a huge Kendrick fan, just thought of him as talented but a little off. Album really shocked me in a good way. And young nikkas and hip hop in general really need and deserve a breath of fresh air, so I'm happy for that too.

For years I've been hearing albums like Common's Be called classics off the bat, then I give them a listen and they're depressingly "eh" to me. I started to realize every few years hip hop is desperate for a new universal classic, and fans try to force the label on a lot of projects. This album feels like a cohesive whole to me, an actual project, something that at least makes me think "shyt, is this a classic for this day and age?" Most albums people call classics these days, I don't even get that far, I can listen to them and just chuckle at the notion they're classic.

I'm also really impressed that Kendrick and his camp had a vision and stuck to it. The label is really pushing the shyt out of this kid and his album, and that's without any obvious radio smashes and no image he can trade on. He's just some little Ewok looking nikka who sounds funny and can flow his ass off. Frankly, I'm shocked he's getting the kind of push he's getting.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Black Ball

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
6,722
Reputation
921
Daps
15,330
Reppin
The Mighty LBC
I feel like this was directed to me so I will respond. First off I always said I liked the cd and it was good music, just not "amazing" as a lot of people on here are saying. As far as his voice, i don't even think it's his voice, just the way he uses some of his words or the random "my nikka"s or "ya bish" just comes of as immature and corny to me. It might just be some west cost stuff but these dudes remind me of the suburban black dudes who tried to be "gangsta" just for fun. The entire story about riding on a nikka in your moms van comes off as corny to me. Growing up if nikkas was robin and shootin it was cause they had to in order to survive, not cause they homies told them to. We didn't have "moms vans" to ride around in. Or parents at home supporting our dreams.

As far as the "post some lyrical lyrics" shyt goes. That was a response to people saying he is an amazing lyricist and better than nas lyrically. So I said prove it and the stans couldn't.

With all that said he is talented this is a good album, great for a debut in today's climate. But not as "amazing" an groundbreaking as his stans make him out to be.

:heh: He only drove the van to Sherane's house.

He does have alot weird eccentricities, and a tad corn factor, but album still came out dope.:manny:
 

Hiphoplives4eva

Solid Gold Dashikis
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
42,423
Reputation
3,805
Daps
152,090
Reppin
black love, unity, and music
Album is entertaining but FAAR FROM classic. In fact, I enjoyed School Boy Q and Ab-Soul's joints more than this. There are some outstanding tracks on here though:

Like bytch, dont kill my vibe
good kid
Maad city
Swimming Pools

The rest of the album is just OK. LUPE's new joint is MILES better than this disc though.
 

Black Ball

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
6,722
Reputation
921
Daps
15,330
Reppin
The Mighty LBC
Before I read the rest of your post, let me clarify my post wasn't directed at you, it was general, and the "post a verse" shyt has mainly been a way to discredit Andre from Outkast for years now, which creates this Benny Hill type of frenetic goofiness where someone posts a verse they think is dope, then the person who wanted the proof of lyricism simply dismisses the verse and then posts a verse by Biggie or Nas or Prodigy or whomever and says "now that's what a lyrical verse is."



I don't actually like that "ya bish" shyt either, nor his Macho Man Randy Savage growl of beeyotch on Backseat Freestyle. I damn near stopped listening to Section 80 the first time I tried as soon as the song "Hol' Up" came on because of the way he was pronouncing that shyt.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA



I'd be interested in someone from around Compton verifying whether Kendrick, Q, Ab-Soul, and Jay-Rock are suburban kids. Kendrick definitely has that annoying hipster style, but a lot of hood nikkas have adopted that shyt these days so I can't call it.

Onlyincalifornia? Megatron? Can someone hood check these nikkas real quick and provide some info?



Oh, the overreaction is amusing to me too. I can't really speak on Nas, because the way cats have put him on a pedestal, Nas ain't even as good as Nas.



I respect that take. If I was directly addressing you I would've quoted you. I didn't even notice who posted "show me a verse" or if it was more than one person to be honest. I've never been a huge Kendrick fan, just thought of him as talented but a little off. Album really shocked me in a good way. And young nikkas and hip hop in general really need and deserve a breath of fresh air, so I'm happy for that too.

For years I've been hearing albums like Common's Be called classics off the bat, then I give them a listen and they're depressingly "eh" to me. I started to realize every few years hip hop is desperate for a new universal classic, and fans try to force the label on a lot of projects. This album feels like a cohesive whole to me, an actual project, something that at least makes me think "shyt, is this a classic for this day and age?" Most albums people call classics these days, I don't even get that far, I can listen to them and just chuckle at the notion they're classic.

I'm also really impressed that Kendrick and his camp had a vision and stuck to it. The label is really pushing the shyt out of this kid and his album, and that's without any obvious radio smashes and no image he can trade on. He's just some little Ewok looking nikka who sounds funny and can flow his ass off. Frankly, I'm shocked he's getting the kind of push he's getting.

No hate but this is how I feel about Nas new album. shyt is a cool album. Dope to run through several times after it drops. But it aint super special or even an album I'm gonna care about months later let alone years later.

Only 2 albums I've called classics in several years was Rae's OB4CL2 & Krit's Return of 4eva. Couldn't even tell you an album before that, that I thought deserved such lofty praise. I aint really no Rae fan either, just try to call it like I see it.

Those calling Lupe's a classic, I feel like are borderline trolling.
 

OnlyInCalifornia

Southern California/Vegas
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
19,938
Reputation
3,710
Daps
52,083
Reppin
The Coli's 420th member
I'd be interested in someone from around Compton verifying whether Kendrick, Q, Ab-Soul, and Jay-Rock are suburban kids. Kendrick definitely has that annoying hipster style, but a lot of hood nikkas have adopted that shyt these days so I can't call it.
@OnlyInCalifornia? @megatron? Can someone hood check these nikkas real quick and provide some info?

Suburban kids? No. I mean technically Compton is a suburb of Los Angeles but there isnt a single person who calls it the burbs. Muhfukkas are desperate to say anything about these guys right now, its fukking corny. I don't get why people can't just say 'i dont fukk with their music' instead of doing the industry plant, they are suburban kids, bs. Q and Jay Rock claim a set and you don't get to fake claim sets out here period.

Jay Rock is from the Nickerson Gardens Projects probably the most notorious projects in Los Angeles. They built a fence around the projects to keep people in, instead of out, that should pretty much sum it up. It use to look like a prison for real. School Boy Q is not a 'suburban kid' either. Ab Soul I dunno much about to be honest.

Kendrick Lamar is not a gang banger, never was, just a regular LA kid who happened to grow up in a bad area hence the whole fukking concept of the album :laugh: People get confused because out in California the style is that jeans and t-shirt or surfer/skater type, no one is running around in khaki suits with flags in their back pocket like its the 90s. Been off that forever now.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

OG Talk

Archived
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,655
Reputation
7,808
Daps
116,244
Reppin
Heaven on Earth
I don't think this album is getting enough praise, honestly. The reason this cd sits well with me is because it comes from the same honest place that most young black men childhood resides. In any given neighborhood, there are maybe at most 10-15 "stars". Be it D-boys, playas, or athletes. The rest of us are sideline spectators to the world that those few stars live. So it's nothing to be a kid that never banged but understand the codes of your neighborhood. It's nothing to be a good student and come from a decent home yet get involved in smoking weed or doing petty crimes due to your influence from your friends. It's nothing to be a kid who parents actually take an active role in your life and well being (exhibited by the numerous phone calls through out the "day" on the cd) when you see other kids who parents not give a rats ass if they go to school, come in at a decent time, etc. One thing that Bomani said that rang true is that we want our rappers to be stars. I take it to a more honest level and feel that I want my rappers to be better than me (craft wise). Too many times we get records written from the "stars" of the neighborhood perspective. Everybody with a deal just so happens to be the biggest dope dealer his hood ever seen. Kendrick told MY story in a better way (craft wise) than I could even imagine. That's why the album is really good to me.

Well said...But after all of that if the project isn't sonically appealing to someone then I completely understand...It sounds good and fresh to ME.. But not everyone will feel that way...

I'm so impressed because this is the type of album I would like to think I would make if I could rap...But when I try to wrap my mind around the creativity that it would actually take, I have to admit that I could never do this even if I wanted too..That makes me appreciate it even more..He makes me feel a bit of awe while being completely relatable at the same time...That's very rare...
 

blackslash

Superstar
Bushed
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
17,946
Reputation
-1,965
Daps
25,307
OMG Im late but I jus copped the album...IM on Art of peer pressure

OOO LAWWD

Thanks be to the industry for planting such a great artist :lawd:

Yall might see me stannin this dude harder than I stan Jay Z

nah that'll never happen :youngsabo:
 
Top