Jay Z says the holy trinity is Reasonable Doubt,Blueprint,The Black Album...

[L&HH]

Pray
American Dreamin
Sweet
Ignorant shyt
No Hook
Success
Fallin'
Say Hello


Black Album is better, but American Gangster is amazing in its own right.

I Know
Party Life

Seriously every song except Hello Brooklyn is a straight 4.5/5 or better. To da nikka that said AG is overrated, man HELL NO, I bet the general public wont even mention that album if you ask them about the best Jayz albums.

For mw Jay-z's best albums are:
1. Reasonable Doubt
2. American Gangster
3. TBA
4. Blueprint

 

[OHSNAP!]

BP
TBA
RD
AG

clear choices for me

 

[BUSINESS AS USUAL]

vol 1 is better than tba and ag..its actually my fav jayz album

 

[the cac mamba]

This AG cockriding has to GOT stop ASAP..shiit has mode every time some righteous dumb ass decides to put that on the level of BA, RD and BP1.

forreal the dude who made these fukkin albums knows what the best ones are

and for the record jay held the movies status back by makin his pseudo-soundtrack

 

[No1]

He's right though.

I feel no need to play No Hook or Pray from AG, I can even let the track with Nas go unplayed.

TBA = all the way through.

 

[Phillyrider807]

Gotta agree!

 

[Busby]

If Hov feels that way

Personally his only classic to me was Reasonable Doubt....BP is overrated...its good...but overrated...and Black Album is a VERY good album...not a classic to me...but a VERY good album...if he would have took out Change Clothes...and replaced Justify My Thug with Ignorant shyt...it would have been an undeniable classic....to me anyway..

 

[Brock Landers]

AG is excellent except for Hello Brooklyn imo

 

[Gifted one]

He's right though, but its respectable to have AG over TBA in my opinion.

 

[@Ease]

Volume 1 & 3 > The Black Album

 

[ProfessionallyTrill]

Gimme AG over TBA

 

[Hurricane Starang]

So hes saying his other albums were filler

 

[mr. smoke weed]

he's talking about his own albums correct?
If so it's
Blueprint, RD and black album

 

[DANJ!]

So hes saying his other albums were filler

Yeah man, that's exactly what he's saying. Because anything that's not included in a top three can't just be good but not top three.

 

[iamduval]

He got it right