Ain't That Something
Superstar
Dan Marino has a little brother who's better than Joe Montana?
My nikka marino deserved a ship for all the stats he put up
If your little brother is better than you...
- Thread starter Lakers Offseason
- Start date
My nikka marino deserved a ship for all the stats he put up
Lakers Offseason
Superstar
If your team needs a game winning drive to win a playoff game, who'd you rather have? Eli or Peyton?
Whichever QB you pick is the better QB of the two
Snitchin Splatter
Working With The Feds
If your team needs a game winning drive to win a playoff game, who'd you rather have? Eli or Peyton?
Whichever QB you pick is the better QB of the two
I'd go with the QB with the most 4th QB game winning drives in NFL history
Lakers Offseason
Superstar
I'd go with the QB with the most 4th QB game winning drives in NFL history
Which one? The one who led his team to two game winning drives to win SBs?
Or the one who threw this td to clinch the SB?
[ame=http://youtu.be/Y79ZGUIs0_k]Tracy Porter's Interception - Saints vs. Colts - YouTube[/ame]
yall gotta be some of the dumbest nikkas to discuss sports. Lemme guess, Eli's 2 superbowl ring which are TEAM accomplishments makes him a better overall QB than Peyton's one ring. Are we arguing which of their respective teams are better or which QB is better?
So MVP awards and individual #'s mean nothing in this player vs. player argument? Cool.
Robert Horry >>>> Jordan
Going by this dumb ass logic, because it's obvious that SB titles is the only thing the thread starter is going by.
nikkas still don't know how to argue player vs. player. Hilarious.
So MVP awards and individual #'s mean nothing in this player vs. player argument? Cool.
Robert Horry >>>> Jordan
Going by this dumb ass logic, because it's obvious that SB titles is the only thing the thread starter is going by.
nikkas still don't know how to argue player vs. player. Hilarious.
Lakers Offseason
Superstar
Answer this my nicca: if your team needed a game winning TD drive in the Super Bowl, who would you rather have as a QB?
Answer this my nicca: if your team needed a game winning TD drive in the Super Bowl, who would you rather have as a QB?
Big Bro
I don't get gassed off winning drives. I want the best QB at my disposal at all times and that's Peyton. The game is bigger than one drive, so don't try that slick shyt. This thread would have been an after thought it the safety and corner did their job on that lucky bomb.
and how about you ans my question
Does Individual accomplishments mean anything in this Individual vs. Individual argument???
Teams win SB titles, not one player. Both the offense and defense is needed to win games. However, things like passing yards, passing td's, rushing yards, rushing td's, tackles, sacks etc. are based on a individuals performance.
With that said...who is better Peyton or Eli based on individual #'s???
Conscious Pilot
Do Better.
Game, Check...Answer this my nicca: if your team needed a game winning TD drive in the Super Bowl, who would you rather have as a QB?
Match.
@Lakers Offseason, i'm waiting nikka
Last edited by a moderator:
Lakers Offseason
Superstar
You don't get gassed off playoff performances? Did you see Eli's play during their two SB runs? THat dude was epic. He went into other stadiums, took beatings, and delivered clutch plays after clutch plays.
Meanwhile, the only SB run that Big Bro had, he was carried by his defense and threw more INTs than TDs. I'll give him the second half performance against the Pats in that AFC championship game, because that was dope. BUT THAT WAS IT!!! All the other Peyton highlight in big games is him gagging breh.
If you're idea of a great QB is the dude that looks great in regular season games, then I guess Peyton is your man
GreatestLaker
#FirePelinka
Payton is better. Eli just happened to be teams that got hot at the right time.
You don't get gassed off playoff performances? Did you see Eli's play during their two SB runs? THat dude was epic. He went into other stadiums, took beatings, and delivered clutch plays after clutch plays.
Meanwhile, the only SB run that Big Bro had, he was carried by his defense and threw more INTs than TDs. I'll give him the second half performance against the Pats in that AFC championship game, because that was dope. BUT THAT WAS IT!!! All the other Peyton highlight in big games is him gagging breh.
If you're idea of a great QB is the dude that looks great in regular season games, then I guess Peyton is your man
Of course I saw his performance in both SB games. So this is strictly a SB performance thread? oh, I was confused by the thread title and first post. Eli had two tries to do what he did in the SB, Peyton has one. I don't know what argument your trying to make...but it ain't working.
Also, if you're going to dance around my question, at least come with a better reply than that. I'm talking reg season and post season #'s, does that make it better? either way you know the answer is Peyton. Which is why he is called one of the GOATs and not Eli.
I salute Eli for what he has done, especially since it's against the pats...but be serious now, he can't see Peyton as a QB. If Eli was playing offense and defense while winning those SB rings then you may have an argument, but he wasnt and QB's aren't just rated on the number of rings they have, because like i said..those are team accomplishments.
Last edited by a moderator:
Why the fukk would that even be a comparison in regards to ELI Payton?
Last edited by a moderator:
because this entire bullshyt is based on sb titles and nothing else, which is a retarded way to judge individual players.
Who has more rings, jordan or horry?
now u see my point?
certain nikkas just shouldn't talk sports, because if you can't understand why this argument is silly then wow. He may be trollin though, but he is duckin his own thread so i doubt it.