If your little brother is better than you...

[Stone]

You can argue the reason why Peyton has much better numbers than Eli is because of the passing offense he plays in, the dome that he played in for a number of years that favored a passing attack thus padding his stats, and the the fact that he played with 2 HOF WRs, All Pro RB in Edge and TE in Clark. Now if you put Eli in these same favorable conditions, you assume that he wouldn't have produced the same numbers as Peyton.

They said the same thing about Brady until they switched his offense to more pass oriented attack and that dude even surpassed Manning in accumulating stupid stats.

So I'm not gonna sit here and hold it against Eli because his offense doesn't dictate him to throw it a shytload of times so he can pad his stats. You guys are easily fooled by that shyt. I prefer to judge a player based on his performance when games really count. And from where I'm standing, Eli >>> Peyton.

1. Peyton just played this season outdoors and still had a better season than Eli has ever had.

2. Eli has thrown the ball at least 500 times a year every year that he's been a full time starter except 2008.

3. Those "HOF" players that you mention have also had the benefit of playing with Peyton Manning. Or haven't you noticed how damn near everybody he plays with has some of the best years of their career.

 

[Lakers Offseason]

No. Especially not considering Manning has played for multiple teams multiple OCs now. And the Giants aren't giving Eli the same amount of control teams give Peyton because he isn't as good.


Manning just had one of his best years outdoors. Played 1 dome game.




Again Manning just had one of his best years with Thomas/Stokley/Decker/Dressen/Tammer/Mcgahee/Moreno. Peyton has proven over his career that he's going to succeed regardless of personnel. This dude was balling with Blair White.



And every since they switched that offense Brady has been just as bad in the playoffs as Manning.



LOL at the stupid ass notion that padding stats is a reasoning behind the offense teams run with Peyton. Eli isn't good enough to put up the numbers Peyton does, so he never will regardless of offense.

And you choosing to judge QBs like Eli off an 11 game sample is pretty standard so I can't blame you, but it's the nonsense, shortsighted generic argument dudes like you resort to...so whatever.

Breh, we can go back and forth, but the fundamental difference is that you equate Peyton's regular season stat accumulating performance as him being a better QB.

You do you breh.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

Breh, we can go back and forth, but the fundamental difference is that you equate Peyton's regular season stat accumulating performance as him being a better QB.

You do you breh.

We aren't going back in forth.

You post nonsense. Someone responds and points out why it's wrong.

You dodge the post and offer no response.

Same shyt been going on throughout this thread.

 

[Lakers Offseason]

We aren't going back in forth.

You post nonsense. Someone responds and points out why it's wrong.

You dodge the post and offer no response.

Same shyt been going on throughout this thread.

Like when you posted about your numbers logic and I blew that out of the water?

Or the fact that your boy Peyton has now gone 1 and done for 7 years and you're making excuses for him?

You stans are about as good as they get

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

You didn't blow anything out the water and I haven't made a single excuse for Peyton in this thread. By all means post examples.

 

[Lakers Offseason]

You didn't blow anything out the water and I haven't made a single excuse for Peyton in this thread. By all means post examples.

Post examples?

Why don't you post your stance and I'll respond.

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

So you accuse me of making excuses for Peyton. I ask you to post examples of me doing so. You basically flat out ask me to post some excuses.

I'm done, you win.

 

[TheNig]

If your team needs a game winning drive to win a playoff game, who'd you rather have? Eli or Peyton?

Whichever QB you pick is the better QB of the two

The guy whose numbers ain't so middle of the road and people keep mistaking as an elite QB