Bro like this is kind of frustrating. I'm a Warren person and I like to think of myself as a progressive but this rose colored purity stuff for every thing is getting absurd. We're talking about the CIA. It's going to be dirty and fuccked up. There are going to be secrets that need to be kept and information that needs to be withheld. Yall treating this like it's as simple as reforming police(which isn't actually simple). This is an entirely different beast.
I think the police analogy works well here. It's actually not as impossible as anti-reform people make it out to be. Dropping the police budget by 30% is not outside the realm of the possible. The whole "Oh, this is too difficult and complex, you just don't understand, trust us!" from insiders who don't actually want to effect reform or change is disingenuous. It's about having the will (which they don't) and the courage. You have to have people who actually
want to reform the institution because they have a different ideology/belief than the status quo. The CIA does not have to be dirty and fukked up, at least not as dirty and fukked up as it historically has been. You could have a CIA tasked with undermining the nascent fascist governments and movements across the world instead of the neocon mandate the CIA has been operating with for the past 50 years. These are the questions I would hope our elected leaders would ask of Biden's CIA director during their confirmation hearing, but I wager that would be a bridge too far for centrists who are indignant at the very concept of public scrutiny of political elites and leadership.
As a fellow Warren-person, wasn't this the entire point of her campaign? Structural change? Reimagining the entire paradigm of our government and seeing how we can shift its foundations to become more responsive to the needs of the people? But we're immediately being told we can't even critically assess our elected leaders anymore? Critical political journalism is being derisively recast as just bullshyt from twitter/youtube/patreon. That's fukking dangerous.
This isn't about purity. Progressives lost the nomination, so Biden has the right to select whoever he wants. But we're part of the coalition, so we have a right to express our dissent or assent. If Biden and the centrist wing chooses to disregard us, then that's the world we will be living in, and the consequences will be felt. We're not asking for any of these choices to be arrested, we're just asking our fellow citizens to engage in factual analysis of their records and decide if these are the people we want in roles of consequence and power at the highest levels of our government.