Let’s start with The Shining. There are a few similarities here. A few on the surface and a few that are a little buried. Both films are about families under assault by a supernatural threat that ultimately tears them apart. Was this similarity something you actively thought about while making The Witch or am I just jumping to conclusions here?
It’s a little bit of both. Honestly, my horror movie appreciation is a little weird. I like Hammer horror movies and I like the Universal stuff. That’s the kind of stuff I could deal with as a kid because anything else was too scary. I look at it sort of nostalgically. I don’t covet bad movies like a lot of people who are really into genre. I just don’t care!
The Shining is one of the few classic horror movies that always scared me and really always worked. When I first started making films, short films, it was a film that I watched a lot and tried to dissect until it wasn’t scary anymore. It took a lot of watchings to do do that. When I watch The Witch, sometimes I’m a little disgusted by how much of my film flagrantly reeks of The Shining. At the same time, I will admit that if it wasn’t for that, I don’t think the film would be working for people at all.