Haiti: Nearly a Million People Took to the Streets.They Want the Western-imposed government out of

[loyola llothta]

Historian Michel S. Laguerre: #Haiti's military created as tool of repression by the Unites States

Published on Jul 30, 2017
Interview with scholar Dr. Michel S. Laguerre about his book "The Military and Society in Haiti" and why the Haitian military was created by the US Marines.

 

[loyola llothta]

 

[loyola llothta]

NOVEMBER 5, 2019
‘International Actors in Haiti Have Been Guarantors of the Status Quo’
CounterSpin interview with Jake Johnston on Haiti
JANINE JACKSON


Janine Jackson interviewed CEPR’s Jake Johnston about Haiti for the November 1, 2019, episode of CounterSpin. This is a lightly edited transcript.

Janine Jackson: The New York Times chose to headline an October 20 report, “‘There Is No Hope’: Crisis Pushes Haiti to Brink of Collapse.” The phrase was a partial quote from a source, a despairing young woman in one of Haiti’s most difficult areas. And the story’s photos didn’t lie: people stepping cautiously through streets full of uncollected garbage, newborns in necessity-deprived hospitals. Nor did the facts: at least 30 killed and hundreds hurt in protests, schools closed to millions of children, layoffs and those with jobs going unpaid, roadblocks, blackouts, hunger and stress in a country in severe crisis. Deeper in the piece was another quote from the young woman’s mother, who, in tears along with her daughter, told the paper: “It’s not only that we’re hungry for bread and water. We’re hungry for the development of Haiti.”

As a point of emphasis, the difference between “there is no hope” and “there is no hope under this system” is crucial. So we should think about how media coverage can hinder, rather than help, that kind of conversation.

We’re joined now by Jake Johnston, senior research associate at the Center for Economic and Policy Research, and lead author for CEPR’s Haiti: Relief and Reconstruction Watch blog. He joins us now by phone from Washington, DC. Welcome back to CounterSpin, Jake Johnston.

Jake Johnston: Thanks for having me.

Jackson: Just to acknowledge, we can’t do justice to the history of Haiti here, but I think it’s fair to say, the more you know of it, the more sense you can make of what’s happening today. I wanted to just start with the question of the real scope or nature of these ongoing, and recently escalating, protests. It’s set up as President Moïse versus an opposition that wants him out. But you say that’s too narrow; it’s really bigger or deeper than that. What do you mean?

Jake Johnston: “What people are looking for is not just a change in leadership, not just to change from one politician to another, but real reforms that are going to fundamentally change the system of governance, and the economic system that has gone along with it.” (image: CGTN)

Johnston: There’s been this narrative, again, that you mentioned, that this is a fight between two political sides. And I think that is really taking a far too narrow view of this crisis, which is not just a month old, or two months old or a year old, but has been building for many years, maybe many decades, right? And this is really a systemic crisis. And I think what people are looking for is not just a change in leadership, not just to change from one politician to another, but real reforms that are going to fundamentally change the system of governance, and the economic system that has gone along with it. We’ve seen the failures of the democratic system, declining participation in elections for more than a decade, and an economic system that simply has produced inequality on a massive scale, and failed to address the needs that are so well pointed out in that New York Times article that you mentioned.

Jackson: Let’s do some history. We’ve complained countless times on this show about how elite US media can portray black and brown countries, and especially those deemed insufficiently pro-US, as “uncivilized” or “backward,” or, in fancier terms, “trapped for years in cycles of political and economic dysfunction.” When the role of outside actors like the US does come in, you need to look alive. So here’s this New York Times historical rendering. They say:

Haiti was once a strategic ally for the United States, which often played a crucial role here. During the Cold War, American governments supported—albeit at times grudgingly—the authoritarian governments of François Duvalier and his son, Jean-Claude Duvalier, because of their anti-Communist stance.

In 1994, the Clinton administration sent troops to restore Jean-Bertrand Aristide to power after his ouster as president, but 10 years later, intense pressure from the United States helped push Mr. Aristide out again.

Now we can’t unpack all of that, obviously. But given that that was the only bit of US/Haiti relations that that story included—and it’s more than some stories have included—what are some key things to know about, specifically, the US role in Haiti and about that history?

Johnston: It’s good to see at least some acknowledgement of the important role that the US plays in Haitian politics, right? I think you look back after the fall of Duvalier and the early movement towards democracy, and you had the overwhelming election in 1990 of Jean-Bertrand Aristide. Focusing just on that coup that happened after that, just nine months into his term, and the fact that there were people on the CIA payroll who participated in the coup and participated in the bloody crackdown that followed, you can really see that as a transformative event that really put Haiti off the rails of democracy, and you’ve seen it further eroding over time.

And, again, you often look at the past when you’re talking about US policy. But I think what’s really important in today’s struggle, and what’s happening today, is taking a look at the more contemporary intervention of the US, and particularly in the 2010 election, where the US government alleged fraud on behalf of the government of René Préval and his chosen successor, and Hillary Clinton even came down to Haiti to force the government to overturn the results without any statistical analysis, and put Michel Martelly into the runoff election. And I think you can see the political fallout that has taken place in the now nearly 10 years since that intervention right there. And I think you’re seeing the collapse of that political system that really owes its power, and position in power, to the intervention of these foreign powers, including the United States.

Jackson: Well, it’s interesting, talking about today. We don’t need to get into how someone at the Times could bring themselves to type the words, “The Trump administration has urged respect for the democratic process.” But what we are seeing is calls from some folks within Haiti for involvement from the United States, and calls from a lot of folks for no involvement from the United States. If we’re talking about interventions from the outside world, other than reparations, what sort of involvement, if any, would the majority of Haitians even want from the US, or from the international community, at this point?

Johnston: Yeah, I think this is a key question. It looks like a bit of a paradox, right? I mean, how can you denounce intervention at the same time as, clearly, there’s an effort to sway international opinion in the current environment? And I think it actually makes quite a bit of sense. To think that that’s straight-up hypocrisy assumes that the status quo is that the US is not playing a determinative role or a significant role in Haitian politics. I think it’s not so much further intervention that is needed, but rather taking their hands off of that system, reducing that intervention, to allow Haitians to actually create a path forward for change.

So often, international actors in Haiti have been the arbiters or the guarantors of the status quo. We’ve seen this concept of “stability” over and over again. I mean, there were 10,000 troops there in a “stability mission.” But what has the stability brought, and who is the stability for? This is stability for foreign investors, stability for the political and economic elite, stability for US politicians who don’t have to deal with the threat of migration or some crisis becoming a political issue for them. But it hasn’t been stability for the majority of the Haitian people. And I think that’s really the fundamental mis-analysis, if you will, of those international actors in Haiti, is that the stability that they’ve sought has only been of an unsustainable status quo. And I think that system is clearly collapsing right now.

Jackson: Let me just ask you one question about the “corruption” line, which is very prominent in the media coverage of Haiti today. When I read a gloss that says the government, the Moïse government, may have “misappropriated billions of dollars meant for social development projects,” I get an image of a benevolent and generous international community that graciously sent tons of social development money to Haiti, and that at that point corruption was introduced. And I’m not saying that there aren’t corrupt Haitian officials or elites, but the idea that we, the international community, gave and gave and gave a lot of assistance, but somehow when it got to Haiti, it got perverted…. What’s your reaction to that?

Johnston: That’s an excellent point. It’s a shame that it has to be said, but, of course, Haitians don’t have a monopoly on corruption. And if you look at the foreign aid system that we’ve set up and perpetuated, we, as the United States, the United Nations, as other international donors, etc., NGOs, this system that we’ve created is one that is inherently corrupt, in and of itself.

If you think about it, it’s really a system of legalized corruption, where, again, we’ve seen money go to expensive salaries, cars, lodging, security, back to head offices in Washington. When I was tracking money after the earthquake, what was so shocking was that I was in Washington, and yet most of the money was both allocated from Washington and ended up right back within the greater DC area.

And so you see this sort of corruption perpetuated on this international scale is often not thought of as corruption, because it’s the system we’ve created, and we’ve legalized, but in terms of wasting money, it’s probably a more efficient system at wasting money than what is traditionally thought of as corruption.

It is, obviously, interesting, the focus of these corruption allegations in Haiti today, focus on a subset of foreign aid coming from the PetroCaribe program. Now, this was very different than other foreign aid in that it actually went to the government, as opposed to traditional aid, which, overwhelmingly, about 99% of it, bypasses the government entirely. And that’s actually a really unique way to approach aid, and something I think the aid community more broadly has coalesced around as a positive development, that you need to involve the local authorities, and that is only through putting money into these local authorities, and building up these institutions and capacities locally, that the issues of corruption will eventually be addressed.

But I think it’s a lot safer for international officials, for international media, to focus on the corruption of the Haitian government, and not, obviously, the corruption of their own governments and their own institutions, which have contributed to this over the long period of time.

And if you take even a further step back, and you look at the system, again, this foreign aid system that we’ve created, it has eroded the power of the state, and the financial capacity of the state, over many, many decades, again, by just bypassing the Haitian state and the Haitian institutions. And the result of that is a weak state that is more susceptible to corruption. And so I think even to the extent that there is local corruption, you also have to look at the international role in establishing the systems that facilitate that corruption.

Jackson: We’ve been speaking with Jake Johnston, senior research associate at the Center for Economic and Policy Research. You can find their work online at CEPR.net. Thank you, Jake Johnston, for joining us this week on CounterSpin.

Johnston: Oh, it’s a pleasure.

Link:
‘International Actors in Haiti Have Been Guarantors of the Status Quo’

 

[loyola llothta]

Government building in Cap Haitien, #Haiti set on fire two hours ago after police beat up an activist.

 

[loyola llothta]

 

[loyola llothta]

A faction of the reprobate right in #Haiti is under the control of James Morrell, director of the Washington-based Haiti Democracy Project - an alliance between DC's right-wing and Haiti's criminal oligarch. They now password-protect their site to plan the next move for Haiti.

 

[loyola llothta]

A faction of the pro-imperialist, pro-oligarch left-wing in #Haiti is under the control of George Soros, who created FOKAL in 1995, a local organization to undermine grassroots social movements. Like the right-wing Haiti Democracy Project, FOKAL funded the 2004 coup.

 

[loyola llothta]

Thursday, November 14, 2019

Amnesty International Report Met with Defiance from Haiti Justice Minister

Outgoing-Justice Minister, Jean Roudy Aly, responsible for the unconditional release of seven highly armed foreign mercenaries in February, issued a defiant response to the report of Amnesty International that found the Jovenel Moïse administration, through the police, was using excessive force against Haitian citizens.

Serving under a prime minister within a government with no legal legitimacy, Minister Aly, rather than giving a considerate and inquiring response, dismissed the Amnesty International findings outright.

He oriented the global human rights organization to inquire from State institutions in its reports. He said human rights organizations should gather information from the ministry, the office of the minister for human rights - unheard of at The Haiti Sentinel -, the Office of the Ombudsman (Office of Civil Protection - OPC) and the National Police of Haiti (PNH).

The ministry under Mr. Aly said that police are often incited to use force because of physical attacks by demonstrators and destruction of public property. Demonstrators and journalists have continued to report that it is the other way around. They claim unnecessary police force against their peaceful protest is responded to with hostility over the affront to their inalienable right.

Mr. Aly invited AI to review video from demonstrations posted on the web. It deserves noting that the Amnesty International press release that accompanied the release of its findings was supported by embedded video and photos of instances where police used excessive force against citizens.

Link:
Amnesty International Report Met with Defiance from Haiti Justice Minister

 

[loyola llothta]

Thank you @KemiSeba1 [Kémi Séba]. Back for the second time this year. #Haiti loves you.

https://www.voanews.com/americas/benin-activist-brings-health-kits-haitis-poor?amp&__twitter_impression=true …

https://t.co/dVTQjdB33r

 

[loyola llothta]

 

[loyola llothta]

 

[loyola llothta]

Tuesday, November 12, 2019

Journalist Lives in Danger after Targeting by Jovenel Moïse Administration

Journalists providing coverage of the Haitian population in protests are repeatedly seen under threat by police, specialized forces, not to mention street gangs and civilians who have somehow obtained police uniforms. Their lives are in even more danger, according to the proprietor of a popular radio station, after targeting by the Jovenel Moïse administration last week.

102.7 FM, Radio Tele Zenith (RTZ) journalists and radio hosts remain most active and most listened to in Haiti for up-to-the-minute coverage of protests and demonstrations in the country. Last week, the Haitian government characterized their work as inciting the public to violence. For the regime cited for repressive actions and violence, even by Amnesty International, this is endangering the lives of the RTZ journalists.

"Some of them (journalists) are even physically assaulted, others verbally. Their lives, those of our employees as well as their families are in danger in the face of these recurring threats...", worries RTZ proprietor and CEO, Rony Colin. Mr. Colin, who is also Mayor of Croix-des-Bouquets said that the radio station was always targeted by the authorities, even from the beginning of the mass demonstrations.

The administration for the radio station sent a letter to Reporters Without Borders (RSF) head of office, Emmanuel Colombié, on October 21, 2019. In this correspondence, it is mentioned that "individuals, heavily armed, escorted by several vehicles, attacked the premises of the local radio Zénith TV." According to the letter, "the lives of journalists and station employees are endangered, given the recorded aggression and assassination attempts."

Moreover, the operation of this station which directs and assumes expressly its editorial line against the power in place seems to preoccupy the government which, in its last note, says condemn with firmness the "irresponsible and incendiary behavior of radio Zenith in the current crisis".

The government mentions "serious, violent and revealing incidents of a new trend in the country where heavily armed civilians are attacking patrols of the PNH". It highlights the case of Carrefour Marassa, where in the afternoon of Tuesday, November 5, 2019, unidentified armed individuals, concealed on the roofs of surrounding houses, attacked several officers of different units of the Haitian National Police, allegedly.

Link:
Journalist Lives in Danger after Targeting by Jovenel Moïse Administration

 

[loyola llothta]

Police officers will march tomorrow (Sunday) in the streets of Port-au-Prince to demand once again better working conditions and the possibility of setting up a union. Police officers confirmed the information to
@PauPPost
. #Haiti

 

[loyola llothta]

As expected, police officers are currently marching through the streets of PauP to demand once again better working conditions. It's their 2nd walk in a month. They are mostly dressed in white jerseys. Some are in uniform. #Haiti

 

[loyola llothta]

Carrefour of the airport. The procession of police officers is joined by a group of protesters (These protesters are not police officers) who demand the resignation of President Jovenel Moses. #Haiti