Michael Vick isn't as physically gifted as Aaron Rodgers?
Are you serious?
Better runner I guess. Passer, accuracy, durability....not even close.
fukkking Cam Newton
- Thread starter El Bombi
- Start date
Better runner I guess. Passer, accuracy, durability....not even close.
yseJ
Empire strikes back
gifted in general, yes
physically, lol no. he isnt close to having the best arm strength
never heard so much drivel in my life. fitting passes in tight pockets require more accuracy than arm strength. pure pocket passing depends on pocket presence, reading defenses and having great footwork and peripheral vision, knowing when the pocket collapses, when to throw the ball away, etc. peyton is still a great pocket passer with an average ass arm nowadays because of his accuracy, feel for the pocket, having great feel for timing and opposite defensesand in the last 5 year or so Ive seen someone throwing thread the needle passes in tight pockets against upper echelon defenses in playoffs...was rodgers in '10
everything else is just your imagination and love for big arm qbs talking.
cam hasnt shown that he can be an elite pure pocket passer at all. hes fukking lost in the pocket.
he's a qb isnt he ?
Do you know what physical talent is?Accuracy is a skill, so is passing, those things an be learned. Vick is faster than Rodgers, can throw just as far (if not further), and is more agile. Rodgers is athletic for a QB but he is not as physically talented as Cam or RG3. Obviously he is the better Quarterback, arguably the best in the league, but this debate is ridiculous
gifted in general, yes
physically, lol no. he isnt close to having the best arm strength
and in the last 5 year or so Ive seen someone throwing thread the needle passes in tight pockets against upper echelon defenses in playoffs...was rodgers in '10
everything else is just your imagination and love for big arm qbs talking.
cam hasnt shown that he can be an elite pure pocket passer at all. hes fukking lost in the pocket.
he's a qb isnt he ?
Cam has the attributes you cant teach....he's not the lost cause youd think the media would have you believe. The things youre speaking on are mental and I agree he's totally out of whack in that regard. I dont know why you hate arm strength but its extremely important.
Rodgers is up there for arm strength....the td pass against the Rams against the grain was one of the crazier passes ive seen
Sophmore slump. But last season was arguably the worst in the NFL history in terms of pass defense so it puts into question his rookie numbers.
yseJ
Empire strikes back
'passer' and 'accuracy' aren't PHYSICAL attributes. physical attributes is how far you can throw the ball and how fast you can run, cut, etc. throwing on the run maybe. 'accuracy' is a skill attribute
yseJ
Empire strikes back
apparently not
'passer' and 'accuracy' aren't PHYSICAL attributes. physical attributes is how far you can throw the ball and how fast you can run, cut, etc. throwing on the run maybe. 'accuracy' is a skill attribute
Exactly, dude really said Rodgers was on a whole other level than Michael Vick in terms of physical talent
Exactly, dude really said Rodgers was on a whole other level than Michael Vick in terms of physical talent
he is
he is
Have you seen Michael Vick's highlight reel? Vick can make any throw Rodgers can and we're not even gonna discuss the speed difference. Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL but Vick is the best athlete that has ever played the Quarterback position unless Cam Newton proves otherwise
Vick cant make that throw going to his right
Accuracy is a SKILL. If we're asking whether Vick has the arm strength (not accuracy) to make any throw that Aaron Rodgers can, then how is this even a question?
yseJ
Empire strikes back
besides being able to throw better on the run than anyone since montana, rodgers' physical tools arent the best in any way. shyt, derek anderson and jamarcus russell had far better armstrength.
SHAQAVELLI
We Are Penn State
Not even going to start with Rodgers vs. Vick. Can't believe some people are still stuck in 2010.