Eli benched for Geno

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

That was his one misstep, doesn't overshadow his overall foot on neck work

That's not a misstep that's fukkin lunacy

If you're trying to argue Hundley is as good as Rodgers I think that qualifies me or anyone to say your football knowledge is horrific

 

[Remote]

And?

Rodgers can’t be overrated because he’s a cac and won a SB?

Coli out here going off reputation instead of numbers?

 

[cheapshot]

Stop it. what was around him on Sunday defines his entire NFL career, yet you think he's defined because he didn't hit anyone on these all go routes featuring slow ass Jeremy Kerley, Jeff Cumberland, David Nelson and Greg Salas.

Why do you have to throw Kerley in with them?
He was the only decent receiver Geno had.

You could have used Stephen Hill, Clyde Gates or Ryan Spadola instead.

 

[Bigblackted4]

So why is this thread 43pages with people in shock over Eli demotion

A bunch of people that fell indebted to him see I’m not a fan of either Geno or Eli that can both go to the for all I care

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

And?

Rodgers can’t be overrated because he’s a cac and won a SB?

Coli out here going off reputation instead of numbers?

You're like Skip Bayless with even less talent

 

[Remote]

You're remind me of Skip Bayless with even less talent

When they can’t refute the numbers this is what they resort to

 

[Bigblackted4]

And?

Rodgers can’t be overrated because he’s a cac and won a SB?

Coli out here going off reputation instead of numbers?

DVOA is terrible when it comes to evaluating quarterbacks the person I go to for that is Ciana Fahey. I like DVOA for team specific stats because it tells a bigger story.

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

When they can’t refute the numbers this is what they resort to

trolling with comments u don't believe. Genius inventive stuff breh

One fact I do know is Geno isn't starting Sunday

 

[Remote]

DVOA is terrible when it comes to evaluating quarterbacks the person I go to for that is Ciana Fahey. I like DVOA for team specific stats because it tells a bigger story.

No stat is terrible. Only people who think they’re meant to encompass more than it actually does for strawmen arguments.

 

[Black Bolt]

That's not a misstep that's fukkin lunacy

If you're trying to argue Hundley is as good as Rodgers I think that qualifies me or anyone to say your football knowledge is horrific

He used comparable stats over an extremely small sample size to make a misguided point. He doesn't , nor would anyone with half a brain, think Hundley is better than the arguable GOAT

 

[Bigblackted4]

No stat is terrible. Only people who think they’re meant to encompass more than it actually does for strawmen arguments.

I agree I misspoke on saying it was trash just not the most efficient way to evaluate quarterbacks. There’s much better measures like yards per pass or yards per completion and stuff like that.

 

[Remote]

The DVOA wasn't used to evaluate Hundley.

It was used to evaluate the defense and how Hundley performed against that quality defense.

 

[Box Factory]

Geno didn’t make a single dumb throw and got sacked for turnovers.


Your critique is so forced

He had several missed throws. He was high or late on several misses

On that final drive for the FG he had a wide open reciever across the middle and went the opposite way only to have it batted down. That was a dumb throw

He also has a bad habit of just kinda jogging and slowly trying to survey whats downfield when he breaks out of the pocket. He has no feel for who's around him and gets drilled out there. And then he puts the ball on floor. He's always done this.


There was nothing in this game that would make me think i shouldn't play the rookie at this point in a lost season if i was the coach

Here's me responding with exact examples and you ducking because it doesnt fit your false narrative.

 

[Remote]

They still mad that Geno last week basically outplayed Eli all year?

 

[FreedS[ohh]lave]

They still mad that Geno last week basically outplayed Eli all year?

Small sample sizes are the only thing Geno stans have and it's not like he even played well against the worst pass defense in the league

Genos never gonna be a full time starter again