Alchemist is my guy! And definitely Top 5 today, and he's been a favorite of mine for a minute, but I find it weird when I see dudes talking about Top 5 of all-time. When you do that, you discount a lot of legends who put in work on actual classic tracks and albums over the past 30+ years. They didn't just have hot beats at the time, they shaped what high quality Hip Hop production was. And set the standard.
Primo is the GOAT, as far as I'm concerned. And it's all opinions, but I think you have to speak on impact and the amount of classic work a dude has done. Dilla, Dre, Marley Marl, The Bomb Squad, Q-Tip, Large Professor, Pete Rock, RZA, Just Blaze, Erick Sermon, Buckwild, Organized Noize, Diamond D, Beatnuts, Easy Mo Bee, Showbiz, Larry Smith, Ski, Kanye, Prince Paul, Madlib, Sam Sever, Quik, etc. There are a lot of dudes that really have entire classic albums and tracks under their belt. Stuff that'll never not be legendary. We have to always keep them and their legacies in mind when we start throwing around Top 5 lists and all that. They put a lot of work in. That shouldn't be overlooked.
But back to the topic, Lulu is dope. This is vintage Conway right here. I wanted a verse from Q though, they cheated us with just throwing that hook at him.