Rick Fox at UNC
All Star
Counting calories is vital. It is absolutely the most important part of any regimen, imo.
Diet will always > exercise, whether your goal is to gain muscle or lose fat. This is an undisputed fact. And with that said, making sure you adhere to that diet is critical. If you're trying to lose weight, chances are you will overestimate your intake of macros. If you're trying to gain weight, you will underestimate. With MyFitnessPal and a cheap scale, there is zero reason not to monitor your calories and macros. It's a no-brainer, and anyone who is serious about fitness would tell you the same.
This is the first bit of good advice in this thread.
@P LaFlame
You've stated that you have a goal of losing a certain amount of weight in five months but then it sounds like you're not really committed to reaching that goal. If you just want to lose some weight or gain some weight and time isn't really an issue then you have no need to track calories and macros.
But if you're saying you have five months, which is ~23 weeks or so, then you should be tracking what happens during that time period.
Maybe split it up in to two 12-week periods and absolutely commit to consuming a certain number of calories per day.
How much do you weigh now and what weight are you trying to get to?