The problem being; Murakami is a bit pretentious. He expects the reader to read his books over and over. For me, that makes whatever "puzzle/riddle", useless. It loses its "flavor" the minute you give no real answers. While Inception did the same thing, there was conflict, and ultimately an over arching story of moving on. KoTS is just a lot of wasted print. And yes while many critics may praise his arrogant style of writing, its like he's forcing readers to jerk him off. No thanks....I got enough of that with Fitzgerald..except, the Great Gatsby has lessons to teach.